Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm surprised anyone wants to argue about this.

"By 2030" is a long time away for a company that was close to bankruptcy about 6 years ago - anything can happen. Full-self driving is also 5 years away if you believe Musk - it's been 5 years away for the last 10 years, though. The first article you cited is basically quoting Tesla marketing material.

Here's the objective picture today (as of end of 2023): TSLA has $74.2 billion in revenue from being a car company. TLSA has $4.8 billion in revenue from energy production and storage. Gross profit is the same story for the two segments - $16 billion and $1 billion respectively. Margins are not dramatically different.

Tesla is a car company.

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000162828024...




A hard to attain science and engineering task is often 5 years away for a long time until 5 years before it is actually delivered. Unlike building widgets building something never done before entails an awful lot of hard to estimate work. Anyone doing software engineering should be familiar with this.

The “5 years for 10 years” meme seems to be confusing a lack of accuracy when giving a precise answer to a difficult to estimate task for either foolishness or fraud, or perhaps both. To me it reads like every software and research estimate I’ve ever seen - a sliding estimate on something you know will deliver but hard to pin down exactly all the unknowables are worked out.


A more honest estimate is "we don't know how long it will take." Guessing that things are 5 years away is borderline fraud when you have no idea how long it will take (eg an uncertain, massive R&D project).

To be fair to you, it was actually "next year" for about 5 of the 10 years that Tesla was promising self-driving, which is a different story (likely actually fraud).




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: