Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

In hub motors might be another automotive example of this. They were used by Ferdinand Porsche and invented in 1896. Ever since engineers keep trying them out as a simple elegant solution. Eventually they will break through I think, but there’s the same allure in the simplicity of it all.



I admire the idea of hubmotors as well, but once mentioned them to a car engineer, who basically said "think about unsprung weight".

Which, now that I think of it again, is a bit silly because most EV mass is battery, not motor.


Shaving unapeung weight down, even by a small fraction of the total vehicle weight, will dramatically affect handling and perceived ride quality. Even though the battery makes an EV heavier than an equivalent ICE car, there is still the need to reduce unsprung weight. Thus, it would be better to have the motor inboard and run a cv axle out to the wheel than have the entire mass of the motor out on the wheel.


Unsprung weight does not have a linear impact.

Increasing the unsprung weight by 10% causes a 100% deterioration in handling and ride quality.

You're suggesting increasing the unsprung weight by about 400%.


> once mentioned them to a car engineer .... now that I think of it again, is a bit silly

No offense, but this right here is peak HN.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: