Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

In what area of science would it take only a week or two to replicate?

It might take several days to a week of literature review just to fully understand the problem. Then you might need equipment, chemicals, cultures, etc. Then depending on the area of science, doing the actual experiment could take several weeks (waiting for reactions, computer simulations, etc). Then possibly tricky analysis and statistics on top of that.

Nowadays, science is deep




Science is very deep; I’m sure that to replicate some studies it would cost as much as performing the original study did.

But whether it’s $10k or $100k, we really should provide the funds to do it. Expensive? Yeah, but not as expensive funding grants for generations of psychology professors and getting nothing—or worse than nothing—in return.

Psychology could fix its replication crisis tomorrow if as part of writing every grant, they also calculated what it would take for another group to replicate their experiments, and put that money in escrow to hire reviewers and replicators who had to sign off on any papers published.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: