Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How am I not honest? The listing shows my cleaning fee and checkout list. Everything is transparent.



Be honest and build the fee into your rates.

Why do you not do that?

What is your rationale for charging it separately?


First, note that Airbnb shows it "built into the rates" when you put in the number of days you are staying when making a reservation. See this article from 2022: https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/7/23444561/airbnb-total-pri...

But to answer your question - because it is a fixed cost per stay.

If you stay two nights @ $250/night, you'll pay an additional $200 cleaning fee (so that would be $350 night if I were to "build cleaning in") If you stay 6 nights @ $250/night, you'll still only pay an additional $200 cleaning fee (so it would be $283/night if were to "build cleaning in").

Airbnb doesn't allow me to charge a different $ based on the number of nights stayed. But they are showing an all-inclusive cost to the user when the user is browsing with their # of days, so there is nothing hidden...

and to your "give it time" statement, it's been over 5 years...


First off: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/travel/airbnb-has-a-plan-...

And secondly if you reread my post you’ll see that I think it’s morally wrong to charge a cleaning fee AND expect guests to clean as well.

That’s double dipping.


I'm a guest, not a host.

I do not think of airbnbs as identical to hotels in every way possible, and I don't want them to be. I am ok with doing some basic cleaning tasks despite being charged a cleaning fee. I naively still consider airbnbs to be a little bit like sharing a space, with an implied social contract. I expect to do a little stuff that is low cost to me, high value to the host. I also know they're still going to have to pay a cleaner. And I really would prefer them to not unconditionally wash and dry the bedding for every single unused bed in the place. That's how our planet got into this mess.

I tend to be way more distrustful of previous guests than I am of the host. There are a lot of nasty and entitled people out there.

You have your perspective. Others of us share mine.


I totally support your right to your view.

As I’ve stated before these are my personal beliefs - and they may have been influenced by my age. I come from a time long before Airbnb was even the merest glimmer of a thought in anyone’s mind, and base my expectations and experiences on that.

Whilst Airbnb started off as folks sharing their properties. It’s now a fully fledged business for many where “hosts” are now corporations who buy properties to let out (in 2021 the figure stood at 28%).

So that also makes me very jaded.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/biggest-airbnb-hosts-canada...


Thank you for that perspective. I spend a week a month in my airbnb, so it is considered more of my second home than a business. There are photos of my wife and I in the house, and I think the house feels "warmer" for guests because it's not just a sterile hotel or full-time business.


My cleaning fee is for washing the bedding, mopping the floors, wash inside the oven, was inside the refrigerator, vacuum all floors, wash all floors, clean every surface, scrub the shower, scrub the toilets, clean the sink and mirror, etc etc.

None of which I expect guests to do. So it's not double dipping.

You've been explained why you're wrong ten times now, and still drone on about it. Maybe airbnb just isn't for you? Book a more expensive hotel instead, and then those thinking my cabin is a good deal can do so and be happy.


This is a public forum.

If I have a strong feeling on something, why do you feel I should not talk about it?

It is your opinion that I am wrong. It is not a fact that I am wrong.

You say you have a cabin - I’ve booked Cabins in the Hocking Hills area of Ohio (not via Airbnb). They’ve never had cleaning fees.

If they can handle this, why can’t you?


> If they can handle this, why can’t you?

Ohh my god, come on, you've been explained this a hundred times by now. It's not that I can't handle it. It's that it's fairer for everyone if the price is set based on the actual cost.

My cabin costs $200 a night to rent, and $100 to clean. If you stay 2 nights that's $500 total, or $250 a night. Do you suggest I just should set the price to $250?

But what then for those renting for 7 nights? Normally they pay $1500. But with your scheme it will be $1750. Or I would have to eat the cleaning cost for those staying 2 days, making no money and instead just pulling it from the market and everyone loses.

The customer doesn't even see the cleaning fee. They see a total price. Then it's up to them to decide if they think it's worth booking or not.

Perhaps this is because I live in Europe, where all costs must be up front. Hence there is no scamming going on here. And I don't care what a cabin on the other side of the world does. I do what makes sense in my local market (people here even bring their own bedding!!). Get it into your head that people want freedom to choose a stay that fits them. If you don't want to care about this, then just don't book.


“And I don't care what a cabin on the other side of the world does”

And there’s the rub. You’re getting very emotive about the subject whereas I am approaching it simply as a customer experience issue.

When I book the cabins I get a cheaper price the longer I stay.

The issue would therefore seem to be that the Airbnb doesn’t provide you the flexibility you desire. The cabin’s I’ve stayed at are owned by different people but rented out by a company that handles such properties in a reasonable manner.

And besides, you continue to ignore my initial first statement: That I feel it’s immoral to charge a cleaning fee AND expect customers to do cleaning.

The original post I replied to stated that they expect the customers to strip the bed plus more cleaning tasks, AND they charge a $200 Cleaning fee.

Even the Airbnb CEO stated he felt that it was wrong to expect customers to strip the bed.

The Cabins I stay are request that when you leave the property you have gathered plateware etc. into the kitchen, and towels etc are left in the shower, and all furniture is left in the basic state you found it.

That takes all of about 10 minutes - which is fine by me. All costs in cleaning and maintenance is taken out of the rental fees.

So no, in my “scheme” costs are not higher because the company I rent through handles rates accordingly.


You broke the HN guidelines repeatedly and egregiously in this thread. We have to ban accounts that post like this, so please don't do it again.

Please avoid tit-for-tat spats in particular. They're extremely tedious and definitely not what HN threads are for.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.


[flagged]


You broke the HN guidelines repeatedly and egregiously in this thread. We have to ban accounts that post like this, so please don't do it again.

Please avoid tit-for-tat spats in particular. They're extremely tedious and definitely not what HN threads are for.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.

Edit: you've unfortunately been doing this repeatedly in other places too - e.g.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39558277

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39552080

Moreover we've had to ask you about this more than once before:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33014240 (Sept 2022)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22668623 (March 2020)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22668616 (March 2020)

If this keeps up, we're going to have to ban you. I do not want to ban you, so if you'd please review the rules and stick to them from now on, that would be good.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: