Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Really good q I'm shocked too. Riffing:

Without Play Store it's not viable/interesting. Also, it's so. much. work. keeping up with Android releases, even inside Google. Wear and ChromeOS are always a version or two behind, and vast majority of the time, it is two versions.

If Google internally wasn't helpful enough to each other, I can't imagine they played nice with Microsoft on this.

The broad business war means there's no incentive for VPs to drive it.

Technical challenges via CTS* mean there's no incentive for 1-3 steps up the org chart to enable it.

The narrow-er business challenge of not having the Play Store is the final nail for any cooperation. I don't think Google is interested in proactively collaborating unless you do CTS.

* Android's CTS, compatibility test suite, has to be passed to get the Play Store, and broadly, it is organized around individual device launches, rather than a subsystem than can run on any hardware.

(n.b. I worked on Wear then Android at Google, 6 years total)




I could be wrong, but I thought passing CTS is only one of the steps to be able to advertise a device as powered by android. To get Play Store which requires GMS, there are additioinal test suites like GTS.


> Without Play Store it's not viable/interesting.

Just install a version of WSA that has the Play Store. Take Magisk along the way too because why not.


Weirdly enough I had to do the compatibility hoops for Waydroid, but not the commonly used WSA+MindTheGapps distro.


What’s n.b.?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: