Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It can take an instant to become disabled: there is no permanent and distinct set of "disabled and "not-disabled" people.



Not to defend GP, but if I suddenly went blind, I really don't know if it would take longer to learn how to use my existing tools with a screen reader or to learn new tools better designed for it. It would be a completely new and foreign workflow either way.


This is not about what tools you want to use, but what tools you're forced to use by your team.

If this were a simple, offline editor, a decision not to focus on accessibility would be far easier to swallow. They seem to be heavily promoting their collaboration feats. If those on your team collaborate using Zed and expect you to do the same, other tools aren't an option.


Fair point. I'm not used to being forced to use particular tools so I didn't think of that.


Have you considered that disability is not always permanent? What if you were temporarily blind? Or could only see magnified or high-contrast UIs? Or you broke both arms, but your feet are fine for using your USB driving Sim pedals as an input device for 10 weeks while your arms heal? Would you still want to learn new workflows to be used over a few months only?

A11y isn't about helping one set of users (those who have completely lost their sight), it's about helping a whole spectrum of accessibility challenges - not by prescribing boxed solutions, but giving the user options customizable to their specific needs.


I did consider temporary disabilities, and don't see how it changes anything I said (which is, again, not much).


The amount of time one is willing to set aside to learn new tools & workflows isn't worth it if they are to be used for a limited period. It's much better to use the old tools one is familiar with in those cases.


You're still assuming that learning the old tool in a new way is faster. That's specifically what I'm questioning.




Consider applying for YC's W25 batch! Applications are open till Nov 12.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: