Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
[flagged] Gemini lying about having data until 2021 (twitter.com/malix_off)
11 points by Malix_off 7 months ago | hide | past | favorite | 12 comments



Interesting, is this flagged because it's a bad quality post or because the people of the "AI" religion feel insulted?


It hallucinated. Nothing new or unexpected.


What is Gemini and why do I have to know in order to make sense of a HN headline?


It's Google's LLM that powered Bard (Since renamed to Gemini)


Whoops, forgot to message you to ask if you knew before posting.


Please don't take personal swipes in HN comments.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


Gemini told me it got access to the data on the internet until 2021, Which is a lie (it can do real-time) So it has invented that information… Weird, considering ChatGPT 3.5 actually only got access to the data on the internet until 2021.


Are you just reposting your own tweet as a HN headline, and then again as a comment? I get the insinuation that you found a smoking gun of Google impropriety, but there's a simpler explanation. It's a next-token-finding machine, so if you ask it things that only other LLMs would be answering online, and essentially no humans answering, you'll get parroting. You lead Gemini into starting with "I am trained on a massive dataset of text and code that includes ..." and then having to find the next token, based on the 2024 internet. Since 99.99999% of instances of that string will be people posting chatGPT chats online over the last few years, I could see how it would fall into the same pattern.


This is probably a result of Gemini having ingested plenty of ChatGPT conversations that include ChatGPT telling the user that it only has access to information up to 2021.

This is not a new problem, either. Once, I had a model (I think it was Llama 2 7B) tell me that its name was Bard. Yeah, right...


Give LLMs another year or two and they'll go full circular.


Thank you for copying the twitter post text, although I cannot even parse what it is supposed to mean.

I would suggest that it would be polite that when someone decides to post some word vomit from twitter, they should also include a translation in the comments.


Classic word vommit




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: