Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Try Jellyfin. It’s the same thing Plex once was but fully open source.



I have (and have a Jellyfin server running on the network). IMO, it's nowhere near as polished as the 2017 version of Plex. Cover art and metadata matching is terrible. Plex seems to handle slightly "off" filenames and folder names far better.

Every so often I update jellyfin and try again, only to find it's still a worse experience than Plex.


I'm more than willing to take the trade off of slightly worse metadata and a less polished UI vs plex reporting all my media, habits, etc to their movie studio bed partners. They've already turned on their users and are abandoning what made plex great to begin with. Once you get used to JellyFin it's really great.


This is why I never take the jellyfin evangelicals seriously. Plex is good software - nothing has been taken away and my experience with it has been consistently good and stable for multiple years.

> plex reporting all my media, habits, etc to their movie studio bed partners

There is no proof that they're doing what you're claiming. From what I've seen, people love trying to to push jellyfin by making things up about plex. Also a polished UI/UX counts for a lot more than the solo-user jellyfin crowd thinks.


Yep, tried Jellyfin, UX was terrible, got back to Plex. If it’s not as good as Plex, it doesn’t matter if it’s open source or not.


> There is no proof that they're doing what you're claiming.

do you recall when Plex started ingesting your media history and then emailed all shared users in your library what you were watching?

Many Plex users were pretty embarrassed to be outed for soft porn to family members and colleagues.

https://www.reddit.com/r/selfhosted/comments/180maoe/plex_cr...


> reporting all my media, habits, etc to their movie studio bed partners

is the claim. What you posted does not support that.


> This is why I never take the jellyfin evangelicals seriously.

It's mostly better not to take evangelicals anything seriously but I don't think you calling them evangelicals is a bit too far.


I have had a devil of a time getting Plex to recognize file names. I wish I could just directly write things to its damn fucking database.


Follow the naming standard:

https://support.plex.tv/articles/naming-and-organizing-your-...

You can go to open subs and use those names alternatively, which follow the standard. Or just use jellyfin.


I have also googled this, and this does not reliably work - especially for things that aren't TV shows, such as videos from YouTube channels or music videos.


for that I dump them in an "other" library and it uses the file name title. though I mainly use it for my blu ray rips.


FileBot is your friend ;)


That said, it does feel like PLEX hsa been introducing better features and cleaner UI since jellyfin launched. I wonder if they keep track of Jellyfin installs on local system. Competition is good.


It's not as good as Plex. I hope one day it will be, it continues to improve, but it's a worse experience. Once they have proper intro skipping, I'll check it out again to see if they have fixed their other issues.


Fwiw, the Intro Skipper [0] plugin is actually fairly straightforward to install and set up and works as advertised (I personally just have it configured to auto-skip).

[0] - https://github.com/306bobby-android/intro-skipper




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: