Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Are these just 3d renderings? If concept trains are anything like concept cars, it'll be more useful to look at the final physical product



I’m not sure in general, but I had a similar thought ~5 years ago when the new London Underground tube stock design was unveiled in the form of concept art. A few months ago they did their first press session with the actual trains, and to a layman’s eye, it’s basically exactly what was in the concept art. I’m sure there are differences for commercialisation and operational details, but I can’t notice them.

Concept cars are about the concept and not intended to become a real car for general availability. Whereas projects like this are typically fairly directly tied to an actual project to replace the rolling stock or a contract with a manufacturer. They may still be a little aspirational and need the details working out, but I think they tend to be much closer to reality.


The overall thing? Not sure. But the seats are definitely real and aren’t just 3d-rendered, as one of the images in the article is an actual photo of those chairs in one of their facilities (i.e., outside of a train).


FTA: "A final version of the design was released in 2021, and production is now underway."

It's a rendering that represents the file design. Train sets have long lead times.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: