Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> [...] just like you can't have classical music without an orchestra (with strings, etc.) [...]

The large body of Bach's work for solo keyboard instruments would suggestion otherwise. Or Beethoven's many works for solo piano. Or Mozart's.




+1 makes me ponder about Knoll's law and whether I am actually misinforming myself by reading comments here on HN.


The irony of your comment should not be lost. But sure let's all join the HN Small Minded Club and comment before we read the article and think. It's all the rage here...like rock music once was. Get it?

Apology accepted. Next time just move along. Thanks.


If you're going to be pedantic, JS Bach isn't classical, it's baroque.


By mentioning Bach, you proved my point. That is, tastes change. Bach is no longer top of the charts either.

Put another way, the author's argument is effectively "the music I like and the music I grew up on is no longer the genre of the mainstream." Wow. That's insightful. Life moved on? As if he's never read a history book.

FFS...you're attacking me? Grow the fuck up. Gawd this is getting tiring.

p.s. Rock as defined by the R&R Hall of Fame is *not* limited to guitars. Whose definition do we believe, the article of the HoF? Gee. Tough call when you're practicing to be another HN prickly person, eh.

Apology accepted. Next time just move along. Thanks.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: