AAA estimates 220 million flat tires annually in the US.[0]
The existence of spare tires has nothing to do with poor observed reliability. It is because of lack of 100% reliability. It's because when people get a flat, they don't want to be stuck and have to be towed. They want to be able to do something about it and get back on the road. All my flats have happened not because I lacked TPMS sensors but because something poked right through. Low tire pressure only accounts for 15% of flats. [1]
If you work for AAA, then sure, trying to convince people to get rid of their spares makes sense. But waiting around for AAA doesn't sound like a fun plan for me, especially when they won't be able to put a spare on for me, but will have to tow me somewhere.
The existence of spare tires has nothing to do with poor observed reliability. It is because of lack of 100% reliability. It's because when people get a flat, they don't want to be stuck and have to be towed. They want to be able to do something about it and get back on the road. All my flats have happened not because I lacked TPMS sensors but because something poked right through. Low tire pressure only accounts for 15% of flats. [1]
If you work for AAA, then sure, trying to convince people to get rid of their spares makes sense. But waiting around for AAA doesn't sound like a fun plan for me, especially when they won't be able to put a spare on for me, but will have to tow me somewhere.
[0]: https://cluballiance.aaa.com/public-affairs/press-release [1]: https://tiregrades.com/buying-guides/how-many-flat-tires-per...