I don't think he has a valid point... everything is taking, there isnt really "making" any more just recombination of factors...
Saying that Making is something like creating Sugared Cereal for Adults misses the fact that you've still just taken the sugared cereal concept and tweaked it
Saying that Making is something like creating Sugared Cereal for Adults misses the fact that you've still just taken the sugared cereal concept and tweaked it