Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I just want decent on-device voice recognition for things like asking the Assistant to send text messages. So tired of having to repeat myself 5 times.



Even with the recent improvements to iOS speech recognition, I've felt that Android recognition has always been better. Not the case?


I've extensively used both iPhones and Pixel phones for years.

Siri is astonishingly, infuriatingly bad. It's hard to imagine anyone on the Siri team uses it daily like I do. It works well ~30% of the time and is bafflingly non-deterministic.

Google is much, much better, but it's still not objectively great. It's closer to 80% of responses being reasonable, which is still unacceptably low.


Siri and speech recognition are somewhat different. iOS seems to transcribe my spoken words reall very well most of the time.


The actual recognition is quite good. It's just the handling of poor/intermittent network issues that is abysmal.


I've had this going back to the Pixel 4. Do non-Google phones still not have this?


I also have only had Pixels basically since they were released. I guess where I have issues is when the phone has a weak signal, and it insists on trying to use it for voice recognition rather than just falling back to local.


The latest Apple Watch models do this and it’s so much nicer.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: