Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It implies that other devices that are not supposed to report their MAC, but do, deserve a high CVE as well.

This has to do with a bug seriously compromising a feature. It does not reflect the overall security rating of the entire device. If I have a one-way data diode sending telemetry from the flight controller to a passenger's entertainment console, it works as intended - which is why they put in a layer1 one-way diode. When you have a feature, you use that feature for a scenario where it is useful.

If the flight controller data diode has a second fiber and allows it to be hacked from a passenger seat entertainment center, that is a high severity. It does not mean every network switch has a high severity security issue, because we don't put those into flight controllers that hook up to entertainment centers.

Let's do a car example. If I rent a Uhaul to move my piano, and it splits in half from the weight, this is a serious malfunction. It does not mean the mini-coop croaking from a piano loaded on it's hood is also a serious malfunction.

Let's do a food example. If I put an empty metal frying pan on a stove and it bursts my house into flames, this is a serious problem with the frying pan. If I put it in the microwave and it does that, that's not a problem with the frying pan.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: