Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Ask HN: Can someone explain to a non US resident how Matt Gaetz ousted McCarthy?
3 points by danielovichdk on Oct 16, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 7 comments
How can such a small fraction of the Republicans get to oust a speaker of the house like that?

It was like 97% backing McCarthy but still he went out.

How is that possible?




Where are you getting that 97% figure?

Due to a recent rule change that occurred when McCarthy was originally chosen as Speaker, it only takes 1 member to call for a change of speaker. The vote to remove him was 216 to 210, which is a majority.


I'm pretty sure it's just a simple majority thing, but someone please correct me if I am wrong. 97% of Republican House members != over 50% of the House.

The Republican majority is so thin, that all it took was 8 or 9 of them to vote no when they called the vote (which itself was only callable because it was a shitshow for Republicans to elect a Speaker a year ago and there was a rule change to satisfy the Gaetz crew (i.e. a rule change that permitted them to do exactly this)).


208 democrats joined 8 republicans in voting him out:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/house-vote-mccarthy-speaker-rol...


As part of the negotiation to get Kevin McCarthy to the speakership back in January, Republicans made a rule change in the House which allowed just one member of Congress to bring up for a vote a measure that would let the entire body vote for his ousting.

Pelosi removed this rule when she was speaker, but to be fair she was also really good at getting her party to stay in line.

It will be interesting to see if Republicans take that rule away to avoid another mess if they manage to vote in a new speaker.


What do you mean Pelosi removed the rule?

Pretty sure this rule has never existed before because of the exact problem it’s caused.


https://www.texastribune.org/2023/10/06/texans-rule-change-h...

"Under rules negotiated in January during McCarthy’s tumultuous first election, any member of the House can motion to vacate the chair — a procedural move that will force a vote to remove the speaker. That was how the process worked until 2019, when then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi significantly raised the threshold."


Wow I had no idea it existed before.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: