Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> independent projects? P

you mean like flatpack and snap which also have the benefit of decoupling .so dependency management?

or maybe like nix which you can run as a package manager on other dristros then NixOS?




Not really. I just meant that an OS team probably should only work on engineering and shipping the actual OS and should not dedicate a minute of their time to running a repository with Audacity or Wesnoth in it (I like and use both). Someone else should (as long as they feel interested).


You are describing the current state of Debian, just with multiple repos instead of one.

The DDs who work on, say, kernel packaging are not necessarily the same DDs who work on Wesnoth packaging.


We already have that.

For one like the other comment pointed out different people internally often already work on different packages.

For the other external repositories are a thing.

But they are often not trusted, and if a package is maintained by upstream often it is only for one or two repos.

So it fix it you would need a repository which can work across distributions. Where maintainers exist independent of the distributions but also the organization is big and reputable enough so that people do trust it.

But to have that you need to use technology which abstracts over differences in distros especially wrt. .so dependencies. Like nix, flatpack or snap.

Or in other words I believe you either have what we have today. Or you have a core OS (which still needs packages and package managing!) and the rest is using technology similar to nix, flatpack or snap to provides package repos across distros.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: