Ask HN: What are some reasons a Show HN post might get flagged?

[romanhn]

When I browse https://news.ycombinator.com/shownew with showdead on, I see several posts flagged into the oblivion. None of them strike me as obviously egregious and I'm curious how they ended up this way. I can understand flagging of obvious spam / undesirable content on the "new" page, but Show HN is where folks show off what they've built. Would love some perspective on motivations behind flagging those messages.

Full disclosure, I did my first Show HN earlier today (something I worked on on my own for a while) and though it got some votes, apparently it also got flagged and while not dead, this prevented it from ever surfacing on the "show" page. Life goes on, but it really piqued my curiosity!

[mtmail]

Those [dead] are not flagged (it would show [flagged]), it's algorithmic. Usually brand new accounts where another old account will need to click 'vouch'. There sometimes aren't enough users browsing the /new queue. Especially all the github repositories became boring to me, for example code that was pushed to github only 5 minutes earlier with no documentation. 'Show HN' is the most misunderstood label and some users use it for blog posts or websites they didn't work on (like a wikipedia).

I remember your website and see it in my browser history so I most likely clicked 'vouch' (browser history doesn't tell).

It has 8 upvotes and not listed on /show. That's usually a sign that friends upvoted. By that I mean accounts who visit hackernews, upvote and then leave again. I'm not saying that happened here, I've just seen this algorithmic behavior in the past, for example I checked twitter and the author posted an 'upvote my submission on $url'. Apparently that's normal for producthunt but discouraged on hackernews. I have no insight into the actual algorithms.

[mtmail → mtmail]

Try again in a couple of days, different time of day. It helps to add a first comment "Author here, happy to answer questions" or similar. On the https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html page you'll find a link "See these tips". The linked comment was written by one of the moderators.

[romanhn → mtmail]

Thanks for your comments! I asked dang about it, apparently someone flagged by mistake. I may get a second chance, and there's always another time like you said. Cheers!

[gus_massa → mtmail]

I agree. I took a 10 seconds look at the recent [dead] posts in shownew. Some are clear spam and other are dubious. This one in interesting https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37790042 so I vouched it.

[gus_massa → gus_massa]

Too late to edit: It was already posted by someone else 2 month ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36917719 (15 points, 6 comments) and by the owner https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36895204 (2 points, 0 comments). I'm not sure if that is "significant attention" as it says in the FAQ. Perhaps the owner is posting too many links to his site, but it looks like a nice project and he is not reposting too much to annoy me.

[gsuuon]

It looks like all the current [dead] links violate the "Please don't use HN primarily for promotion" guideline.