Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> "Man bites dog" and "dog bits man" have two different meanings based on word order. In German, both orders are possible and it still has the same meaning.

That's not correct. Both orders are possible but they don't have the same meaning. The word order in this example has the same effect in German as it has in English.



Der Mann beisst den Hund.

Den Hund beisst der Mann.

Both sentences have the same meaning.

Beisst der Mann den Hund? would make it a question.

"Der Mann den Hund beisst" is grammatically wrong but still understandable.

I googled it and, strange coincidence, they even use my example: https://www.dartmouth.edu/~deutsch/Grammatik/WordOrder/WordO...

English tends to rely mostly on word order to indicate the grammatical function of a word or phrase, while German uses inflections. The German endings, such as those indicating the nominative, accusative, dative, and genitive cases in three different genders, allow for some greater flexibility in clause construction. Hence "Der Hund beißt den Mann" and "Den Mann beißt der Hund" both mean "The dog bites the man" (as opposed to "The man bites the dog"). Nevertheless, German word order is extremely important, even when it is not vital to meaning, and its correctness plays a major role in how a foreigner's command of the language is evaluated.

At the same time, word order is an infinitely complex aspect of language, never wholly mastered by non-native speakers. Very few rules cover all possibilities, and context often trumps other considerations. When Robert Frost writes, "Something there is that doesn't love a wall," it's poetic; if someone with a foreign accent says the same thing in conversation, it sounds like Yoda.


The literal translations of your examples, which don't have the same meaning, would be:

Mann beißt Hund

Hund beißt Mann

You added articles (der, den) which are not present in your English examples.


Yes, but I am not sure that "Mann beisst Hund" is even a sentence. Sounds like a Newspaper slogan. I don't think a German teacher would let this slip in an essay except if it is done on purpose for style reasons.


Yes, it could be a newspaper headline. Your examples need articles (the man, the dog) to be correct.


I'm perplexed by this and never heard of it (I'm not a native german speaker). How would you then say "the man bites the dog"?


The most common way to translate this would be:

Der Mann beißt den Hund.

This emphasizes that the man bites the dog. (Who bites the dog? The man.)

The other possible translation would be:

Den Hund beißt der Mann.

This emphasizes that the man bit the dog. (Whom does the man bite? The dog.)


The man bites the dog (my example):

Der Mann beisst den Hund. Den Hund beisst der Mann.

The dog bites the man:

Der Hund beisst den Mann. Den Mann beisst der Hund.

This is an easy example because inflections are not really important here. Nouns can change and indicate things like ownership. Chair/ House - Stuhl / Haus for example.

Der Stuhl des Hauses. Haus changes to Hauses, indicating an ownership.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: