On the other hand, if someone has a child who is aggressively attacking anything and everything in site, no matter how they might have heard about PANDAS, I would argue that antibiotics might still be the lowest risk intervention and most prudent option to try if they fit the profile.
Yes, antibiotic resistance is a concern if you start handing out antibiotics like candy, but if PANDAS is truly as rare as everyone would have you believe, then prescribing antibiotics to every kid that comes in with a PANDAS profile is not going to move the needle much with regard to global antibiotic resistance.
Alternatives:
Prescribe them anti-psychotics or some other medication to sedate them?
Likely much higher side-effects and risk profiles than antibiotics.
Send them to a therapist in hopes that the therapist can behaviorally condition that aggression away?
Bad news: talk-therapy for aggressive behavior in children has terrible outcomes. Most likely scenario in the mental health system is that they end up in an intensive group treatment setting somewhere with other aggressive children, learn more sophisticated aggressive behaviors, and gradually get worse.
On the other hand, antibiotics have a fairly low risk profile. Some pediatricians do literally hand them out like candy when kids come in with an ear infection or sore throat. Maybe stop prescribing antibiotics for those kids, tell them to try some tea tree oil or some other natural remedy, and save the antibiotics for the kids who fit a PANDAS profile instead?
Yes, antibiotic resistance is a concern if you start handing out antibiotics like candy, but if PANDAS is truly as rare as everyone would have you believe, then prescribing antibiotics to every kid that comes in with a PANDAS profile is not going to move the needle much with regard to global antibiotic resistance.
Alternatives:
Prescribe them anti-psychotics or some other medication to sedate them?
Likely much higher side-effects and risk profiles than antibiotics.
Send them to a therapist in hopes that the therapist can behaviorally condition that aggression away?
Bad news: talk-therapy for aggressive behavior in children has terrible outcomes. Most likely scenario in the mental health system is that they end up in an intensive group treatment setting somewhere with other aggressive children, learn more sophisticated aggressive behaviors, and gradually get worse.
On the other hand, antibiotics have a fairly low risk profile. Some pediatricians do literally hand them out like candy when kids come in with an ear infection or sore throat. Maybe stop prescribing antibiotics for those kids, tell them to try some tea tree oil or some other natural remedy, and save the antibiotics for the kids who fit a PANDAS profile instead?