Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It seems that the synthetic stone is not the cause, but highlighting the problem: poor enforcement of safety standards and inadequate PPE provided to workers.

Just because there's more silica doesn't mean that it's suddenly unsafe whereas cutting granite is safe. Even drywall or cutting concrete you're supposed to wear PPE.




> Even drywall or cutting concrete you're supposed to wear PPE

Yeah, but it doesn’t kill you within a few years if you don’t, right?


It never leaves your lungs though. In the last 20 years we went from "dust masks are for wimps" to "wow not wearing PPE is terrible". One small silver lining of covid is that even relatively oblivious home owners even wear PPE for small projects now. Smoking OR inhaling large amounts of dust might not kill you, but both are bound to make you miserable later in life. There is already a steep drop off in lung cancer deaths, peaking in the early 1990s. Right now we're down to about 1930s level despite having nearly triple the population.

You can buy a cheap yet very comfortable 5000 or 7000 series respirator from 3M for about $20 and the "pink pancake" P100 filters are another $12. If you're a hobbyist those ought to last you a year, maybe even 5 depending on what you're cutting. I do metalwork as a hobby and I can definitely feel it in my lungs (and taste it) the next day if the garage door is shut and I forgot to wear the respirator.


Metalworking apprentice here, I started wearing a respirator regularly after seeing the gunk cleaned out of my nasal passages by using a neti pot.


Just blowing your nose the next day and seeing all the black iron shavings was enough for me.


Cutting cement boards with a diamond blade is pretty god-awful for your lungs. On the order of few years.

Effects depend on the particle geometry.

But as a general rule of thumb: if it's biologically inert and tough enough to stick around for awhile... it'll just stay in your lungs. E.g. fiberglass, cement, rock, paint.

I wear a respirator a LOT more these days than I did when I was younger.


It is dose related although the silica never gets out of the lungs.

Demolition, sanding drywall compound all is bad without PPE and Hepa filters.


Concrete is silica.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: