Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We pay for it one way or another. I'd rather pay for actual usage instead of getting taxed for stuff I might or might not have used.


In the US you get it from both ends. You pay for insurance, they decline your claims, you have co-pays, minimums, etc. and then you pay more than you otherwise might because the hospitals have to cover those who need care but don’t have insurance. That’s why your aspirin is $300. You’re paying for lots of other people.

And then you also pay taxes for Medicare and Medicaid programs, the VA, and other various, duplicative programs.

I don’t have a strong opinion on either system on its own philosophical merits, but what I see today is that the health insurance industry is a jobs program with extra cost added in for profits and I’m just not really sure what the point of it is.

If we are willing to let people die on the streets and refuse care, let’s get the government out and just go all-private. If we aren’t willing to do that we should drop the jobs programs and waste (insurance) and just go with tax-based healthcare and eliminate redundant programs (Medicare, Medicaid, etc.) and also the subsidization of insurance companies.

Getting people the care they need to is almost certainly going to lead to a healthier and happier population that’s more productive as well, which is another economic benefit.


Absolutely not true and this is simply American propaganda. The truth is American insurance industry is an extremely inefficient middleware that makes everything more expensive and worse than other developed countries. [1]

[1] "US spends most on health care but has worst health outcomes among high-income countries, new report finds " https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/31/health/us-health-care-spendin...

Not to mention it's complete lunacy to think taxes are low in the US. I live in US but also pay taxes in a different country (that I'm a citizen of) that has healthcare and all the Federal tax I pay to US is significantly more (the other country is a fraction of fraction of US taxes). Not to mention, US taxes are extraordinarily, out-of-this-world level complicated if you have foreign assets so you pay thousands of $$$ to a CPA as well.


I'd much rather pay a small percentage of my income and have a guarantee that my fellow Americans aren't suffering through treatable illness.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: