Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

First of all,

I'm not an idiot

No, you are. Everyone is an idiot; it's a sliding scale. Some people are more or less depending on their circumstances. And you become a little less of an idiot the older you are and more mistakes you make. But that's beside the point.

Skipping college has nothing to do with whether you're successful professionally (unless you plan to work in a field where degrees are prerequisites). Anyone can make something of themselves without that piece of paper. You can be the next Bill goddamn Gates without going to a single lecture. I think being successful is relatively straightforward, and that achievements are just a product of how much effort you put into them.

On the other hand, college can give you all the weird shit that matters later accidentally. For example: [Steve] Jobs later said, "If I had never dropped in on that single calligraphy course in college, the Mac would have never had multiple typefaces or proportionally spaced fonts."

It's really like a really tiny specific version of the internet with walls and faces and casual random interaction that you don't get if you're on your own. People need outside stimuli that they would not normally obtain just by living their life and trying to get a specific job or going after what they think they're expected to. Jobs was a big proponent on experimenting and exploring (not trying to suck Jobs' dick here, but he was right about how outside influences are so... influential)

And it's also a great place to get laid.



> [Steve] Jobs later said, "If I had never dropped in on that single calligraphy course in college, the Mac would have never had multiple typefaces or proportionally spaced fonts."

This point is brought up quite a bit. If you replace college with sitting in front of a TV or playing video games, then yes, college becomes a far more stimulating environment.

If, on the other hand, you devoted 4 years to traveling to every country on this planet, you can spend 1 week in every single country. How rewarding would that experience be? How much would you learn? How would it change you? And all that traveling will still cost you less than tuition at a public university.

> And it's also a great place to get laid.

I can't argue this point. However, I will note that you do not have to be a matriculated student to enjoy the benefits of the student body, if that's your cup of tea.


For most people, college is sitting in front of a TV and playing video games.


I think travel is hugely under rated as a people builder.

This is an unlikely story of how a college dropout learned that college is really important. Kind of.

I stopped going to college after 4 years and 7 different "majors". I couldn't find anything I was interested in enough to study for another four years.

I had no skills.

I waited tables. I worked in a deli. I talked my way into an entry level job at an online retailer. I worked my way up into the office from the warehouse in a few weeks. I made a lot of contacts and got a lot of job offers from that little job.

I turned them down. A friend bought Dropzone and I got a job working for him. It was shit work, I was a van driver, but it was after a four month trip to Brazil and the people were fun.

I learned to skydive and in 3 or 4 months he had me running the place as his operations manager. We started little, a tiny 4 seater plane and a minivan. I negotiated contracts, won us a sweet lease on a huge, brand new turbojet aircraft. I hired instructors, brought us from film to digital video (no small feat! we had to figure out how to edit 70 videos a day - while customers waited). I was even lucky enough to run a Groupon when it was just another stupid online marketing gimmick (so we thought. imagine our surprise when we sold 1000 jumps in 3 days, at the time 50% of our annual traffic.)

My girlfriend's brother died and she had to fly home to the Philippines on a one way ticket with no money for a return. I slept thru her calls and woke up to a text just before she boarded her flight at SFO. A few days later I helped my friend find a replacement for me, sold my car and bought a plane ticket. We spent 2 months in the Phils, Thailand, Malaysia and Singapore.

I came back with -$238 in my bank account.

I did odd jobs on Craigslist; I set up people's email accounts, packed boxes, synced computers to other computers for people. I sold a lot of my stuff I had in boxes.

I saved up and got myself an instructional rating.

In five months this past summer I made $30k - enough for my girlfriend and I to travel around southeast Asia for the past 5 months. Thanks to the flexibility of the skydiving industry it took me 4 exploratory emails to get 3 job offers. I'll be heading to NYC in May to work for a few months before I pack up and take off for another 6 months.

Do I want to be a skydiving instructor for the rest of my life?

No.

If anyone here says they want to work their current job the rest of their life they are lying or autistic.

That said, I'm really, really happy with where I am and even more happy that I stopped going to college.

This is all because of one specific friend, the one who bought the Dropzone. He was around 30 when we met. I met him through a roommate. The roommate was my age, 21 or 22. He and I lived with about 12 other people (it fluctuated from 9 to 14. I rented a walk in closet for $250, another friend Bart rented out the hot water heater space under the stairs for $300).

It was a college house. They all went to UCSC. I did not. I had gone to Highschool with one of them and moved in when they rented the house after moving off campus their Junior year.

College is a great, great thing for some people. To me, the value I see in it is not necessarily what you learn (except obviously for science related majors and others who learn specific, specialized skills), but who you meet.

Who you know, you real social network, has been a huge indicator of success for me and others.

My unusual path would have been impossible had I finished college or gone the traditional 'straight to a 4 year uni' route rather than dropping out of city college.


And I'd like to add that more than just providing external stimuli in service of some other goal, education is a goal in and of itself. It truly does broaden one's horizons, makes one able to look at the world from different perspectives (if one's smart enough). It can make you a deeper person, which is an experience much more pleasurable than many so called "achievements".


People keep mentioning this horizon broadening effect, I'm not sure where this comes from.

My most horizon broadening experience at college was from learning to look after myself and become more independent but that was not from the college itself.

Most of our classes were learning something about Java or about some algorithm etc.

Sure, some of it was interesting stuff that made you think but I don't think there was any extra value because I had taken a class vs having read a good book on the subject or participated in online discussion.

Most of college was people fretting over how much work they had to do for some individual class to avoid taking their average down.

The deep philosophical debates that everyone imagines happening at college seemed quite rare from what I experienced. I went to quite a good college too but most people were more interested in football, drink and women.


It comes from literature classes; history classes; philosophy classes. Obviously not from data-structures class, although there's a lot to learn there, too.


Indeed. Even though the liberal arts survey classes everyone was required to sample were by their nature superficial, they did provide at least some exposure to a world wider than engineering and math.

I remember my American Literature class (at an engineering school), the first day the professor asked everyone to name the last fiction book they read. Every single person in the class, every single one, named a Tom Clancy novel. There was a benefit in pushing the horizons here.


Thing is people still repeat this same thing in the UK where if you take a CS degree you will most likely take 0 classes in literature, history of philosophy since your degree will be focuses from the start specifically on the thing that you are studying.

I believe most countries university systems work in this way too.


I actually found the more mathematical components of the UK CS course I did to have the "horizon broadening" effect - probably two-thirds of the classes we had were maths in one form or another.

They didn't even really try and teach programming as a practical activity - you were pretty much expected to pick that up by yourself. Although we had to do a lot of development during the 4 years.


Though can you opt to take these classes? That's the whole point, using the opportunity to broaden your own horizons and do what YOU want.

If all you want to do is follow the script or syllabus, then yes, skip college.


Possibly but it's generally not encouraged. In my 3rd year I got to take 2 optional modules we were pushed in the direction of taking specific project management courses in the business school.

I did take one module in English which was fun but nothing I couldn't have got from a creative writing class.


So, you learn to write an essay.

"The question as to whether " ... "can only be answered by considering the subtleties, nuances and shades of meaning of both the question, and the state of" ...

Then you write 3-300 paragraphs of purple prose expanding on this point.


> I'm not an idiot.

Yes, I am an idiot in those terms. My point was, I'm not just making a mindless decision. And to some my reasoning may be off by scores, but it's still a choice that I have made after hours of thinking hard and research.


You've made a decision to shut yourself off from knowledge and insight that are hard to come by any other way. Spending a few years in college is the easiest, shortest route to some pretty profound insights, and you say, "nah".

I'm not saying that you won't have a fulfilling life, and I'm certainly not saying that going to college could influence its outcome. I'm just saying that you've made your decisions based on some very stupid assumptions. It would have been better to say, "I'm not going to college because I don't feel like it, and I want to see where life takes me". I can actually respect that. But making such a decision, or any decision for that matter, based on false assumptions - actually, criminally negligent and outrageously stupid assumptions - is just... dumb.

Actually, you know what? It probably wouldn't have made a difference. You look at life from such a practical point of view - jobs, "achievements", "lessons" etc. - that it would have been hard for you to really gain much at college, and maybe most people are the same way, even if they do go to college. I can only pity them, because successful as they may become, they lead a pitiful life: the life of the willfully blind.


Spending a few years in college is the easiest, shortest route to some pretty profound insights, and you say, "nah".

I strongly disagree that this is a universal truth. As just one example, I'm finding the Stanford and Udacity courses I'm taking more rewarding than any of the courses I took in college, for a fraction of the time investment.

But making such a decision, or any decision for that matter, based on false assumptions - actually, criminally negligent and outrageously stupid assumptions - is just... dumb.

Really. So college apparently doesn't always effectively teach civility in discourse.


I felt your comment about civility in discourse to be spot on. What would some of the denser communities of highly-educated people look like if this were hammered on for the first two years of university?

I'm certain hn would benefit from it.


> I can only pity them, because successful as they may become, they lead a pitiful life: the life of the willfully blind.

May I ask, what are they (or we, since I count myself among that number) blind to? I only ask out of curiosity, not animosity.


Blind to seeing life as more than a series of goals. Blind to seeing the world through the eyes of, say, a medieval christian mystic, a french existentialist, or a crazed 19th century Russian. Blind to seeing how things we've come to view as obvious truths are simply manipulations by the powerful meant to keep them in power.

Now, I realize I may have come across as an arrogant prick in my previous comment, but it pains me to see that because some aspects of technology have become so easy to pick up, it is programmers, of all people, that start viewing (institutional) education, for all its flaws, as superfluous. I think I wrote a comment on a something Paul Graham said in a conference keynote, that it's become almost obvious that all hackers care mostly about money and "success". I think this is a direct result of looking at the world through "hard data" and "logical conclusions" that's become the norm in this community. Now I see that instead of developing our healthy amount of curiosity, hackers are shutting themselves off from some important avenues of knowledge because they think the have all the "data".


I totally agree with you about the importance of perspective and deep thinking. I hammer on about those, myself.

But that has to be a fire you already have, something you seek on your own, or all the clever, insightful, Robin Williams-Oh Captain My Captain-heavy university classes in the world won't help you. And if you seek it on your own, you don't need the university classes to find it.


If you seek it on your own you may not need university classes to find it, but it sure is the easiest way to start - have someone who's traveled this way before point out some good starting points.


I don't take it lightly. I don't just say "nah", college is a joke. I respect college, and college is filled with brilliant people. Colleges that have decent programs also cost a decent amount. I don't want to graduate with mounds of debt. I know it's possible to work it off while in school, and financial aid, etc. but the fact of the matter is a lot of people have a lot of college debt. WHO KNOWS, I could participate in a new collegey startup in a couple years, I might decide to go in a couple years, but I wanted to make the point that not going to college doesn't mean automatic couch potato with no opportunity.


I see. These are important things to consider. But I think what you've written actually shows some insecurity about your decision. Like you felt a need to say, "see, I'm not a couch potato". Insecurity is good, and I hope you take every opportunity to learn, in college or anywhere else, as much as possible, but not only to improve your "skill set" or your "job prospects", but to make your perspective richer.

If you do decide to go to college, I hope you'll view it as an investment in yourself, not as amounting debt, and make the most out it. It is far from providing everything a person needs to learn, but it's a good enough starting point.


It's not really a decision that can be well reasoned when considering how it will affect the rest of your life, because there's so many ways it can affect you. You might meet your wife. You might meet your start-up co-founder. You might learn some nugget of philosophy or history or something that changes how you think, or influences a critical decision later in life. There's no way to know. But not having that exposure will surely not benefit you much at all.


But doing other things, you can have even more exposure if you try hard enough. Traveling, talking, networking, and not being confined to one college campus the majority of the time is a benefit. I wanted to go to Boston this week, so I bought a ticket and am going. There are exchanges you make on this path. But each path has it's own shortcomings.


You have more opportunities to travel when you are in college and don't have a full time job. You can go abroad, participate in traveling teams or groups of kids going to competitions. A lot of what you are doing can be done in college.

The thing is, college isn't hard, it's easy. That's why for someone like you, it would be a great experience.

Your real reason for not going came out in the comments---it's expensive and you don't want debt. With these experiences you've written about, you'll be able to get into a great school and most likely with a scholarship. Your blog post would make a kick-ass admissions essay to Harvard.

It seems like you already know there are ways to minimize the cost of college via scholarship, financial aid, and working hard during college. Many people do this.

You are really arguing that college isn't worth the effort, yet at the same time you are no stranger to hard work. So, there's really no reason for you not to go to college. Working hard, which you are all about apparently, is all you need to do to ensure it's a net positive decision.


You have to have money to do aforementioned traveling. To this day I don't understand how people can just travel all the time and spend money while they are in college unless they use loan money or have wealthy parents. I don't want to do number one, and number two isn't true. Again, they both have their pros and cons, I just am choosing the lesser tried path.


Number three: unlike humanities majors, someone with CS skills can make serious money freelancing while doing well in school. I more meant programs that are funded by the school---otherwise, you'd pay for it the same way you do now.

It sounds like you are willing to self-reflect and haven't absolutely closed of all options. Best of luck.


It's great that you put a lot of thought into this (maybe, or it could be just as easy as seeing what in front of you, who knows right? some people think for the long-term some people thought they think for the long-term based on a recent, possibly anomaly, trend).

If you can be successful one day that's great. Having said that, I'm a little bit ... sad for the upcoming generation of people in the IT industry (yes, I'm putting you in IT field in general). Less barrier to enter means commoditization. Soon enough people of your kind will be pay lower and lower and lower.

Let me play the devil's advocate: Why should I pay people like you big dollars if anybody, dime a dozen, can do it?

Good luck to you.


Everyone 'a dime a dozen' can't do it. I want to be the best. There's only a small percentile of people that have a strong design sense and can also program, and do it well. That is my goal.


I suggest you audit CS classes at Berkeley or Stanford if at all possible. I'm also a very practical programmer, but being exposed to the ides and theory are important, if for no other reason than you are aware they exist and gain an expanded ability to conceive of what is possible.


I think you're on the right, niche, track in a way: design and program. You're missing something else too: Operational Support (i.e.: Sys-Admin, Net-Admin). These days people are looking for a creature by the type of "DevOps": can program and do operational support.

The future is definitely a little bit bleaker for coder generalist because the current trend is leaning toward making sure everybody can code to some degree (which surprisingly is led by Microsoft Sharepoint, InfoPath, Access, VBA, Excel, LightSwitch and not Rails + JavaScript) because let's face the fact: hiring is expensive, hiring a software developer is even more expensive.

Soon the requirement would probably be: to design (UI), to program, to test, to maintain, to support operation, and to understand business.

Maybe you should explore the market a little bit further than the two skill set you mentioned because of 2 things:

1) There is a possibility that one day that making a good looking software is not as hard as it used to be once people catalogue the patterns and best practices. Once these patterns, best practices, and the tools exist, suddenly the bar of creating good looking UI and decent usability becomes lower and cheaper.

2) Not everyone wants to pay premium on good UI. These days, programmers can come up with a decent workflow and minimal UI and people are OK with that as long as it solves their business problem.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: