> the idea that you should instantly short circuit any situation where you receive a phone call (or other message) and someone starts asking for information
It really irritates me that some significant companies openly encourage customers to ignore this advice, teaching then had practise. The most recent case I know of is PayPal calling myself. It was actually thenm new cc account, I thought I'd setup auto payment but it wasn't so I was a child if days late with the first payment) but it so easily could have not been. The person on the other end seemed rather taken aback that I wouldn't discuss my account or confirm any details on a call I'd not started, and all but insisted that I couldn't hang up and call back. In the end I just said I was hanging up and if I couldn't call back than that was a them problem because at that point I had no way of telling if it was really the company or not. At that point she said she'd send a message that is could read via my account online, which did actually happen so it wasn't a scammer. But to encourage customers to perform unsafe behaviour with personal and account details is highly irresponsible.
It really irritates me that some significant companies openly encourage customers to ignore this advice, teaching then had practise. The most recent case I know of is PayPal calling myself. It was actually thenm new cc account, I thought I'd setup auto payment but it wasn't so I was a child if days late with the first payment) but it so easily could have not been. The person on the other end seemed rather taken aback that I wouldn't discuss my account or confirm any details on a call I'd not started, and all but insisted that I couldn't hang up and call back. In the end I just said I was hanging up and if I couldn't call back than that was a them problem because at that point I had no way of telling if it was really the company or not. At that point she said she'd send a message that is could read via my account online, which did actually happen so it wasn't a scammer. But to encourage customers to perform unsafe behaviour with personal and account details is highly irresponsible.