Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It looks like you didn't read my second paragraph.

My point is that few if any Republicans want to do anything about the labor impacts if globalism, until signing onto chip factory subsidies.

(Well, that and domestic oil production, which contributes to destroying the goddamn planet. But I get the idea that if we're gonna burn it we might as well burn ours. Unless we're playing a long game of exhausting global supplies and sitting on a rarer resource.)

Yes, conservative voters are probably more sympathetic to domestic production, but so are progressives in some instances. Cheap foreign factories and illegal immigration drags down wages and weakens unions.




>Cheap foreign factories and illegal immigration drags down wages and weakens unions

But you can't outlaw foreign competitors from being cheaper than you, any more than you can pass a law against the tide coming in tomorrow


You can demand domestic companies and importers document and attest to domestic standards of living and welfare (health plans, etc). You can tariff items which are made by slave/subpoverty labor. You can subsidize critical industries.

Or, if the concerns are less about "how bad things are there" and more "what about jobs here", we could be spinning up more government jobs programs, more free college, more welfare here so that it doesn't matter if we lose textiles or manufacturing.


>You can tariff items which are made by slave/subpoverty labor

What are 'normal', middle-class wages in developing countries are 'extremely cheap' by US standards. You can't really solve that problem unless you tariff literally everything.

Subsidizing critical industries- sure, I guess. What's the definition of that? Does it include cars? Clothing and shoes? Appliances? Vacuum cleaners? I don't think anyone's disputing that like military goods need to manufactured domestically, but kind of by definition 95% of goods are not 'critical'


Aren't import tariffs a means to raising prices of foreign competitors?


Sure you can, that's a matter of foreign policy change or, as someone else pointed out, import tax hikes and export bans (on e.g. chip technology, but also up until a few decades ago, encryption technology)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: