Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Earthquake strikes Southern California with preliminary magnitude of 5.1 (sfgate.com)
21 points by maxbond 9 months ago | hide | past | favorite | 28 comments



At this point, I think SoCal may just be cursed. Horrible traffic, smog from wildfires, a tropical storm, and an earthquake?! I think that should be a cue to move out before the LA river turns into blood or frogs start raining from the sky.


Well building cities on a major fault line is more akin to cursing yourself IMO. I guess people are betting "the big one" won't happen during their lifetime. The same with traffic, as it's caused by poor planning. The others are really acts of nature.

Ps not judging here, I'm just qualifying :) I'm from the Netherlands, from a part that was most decidedly below sea level which is also inviting disaster obviously. Especially with the rising sea levels. And one huge disaster also happened in the past.

We also have an entirely human caused earthquake problem in the northeast due to the empty spaces left by natural gas extraction.


To provide some context, the fault zone you're talking about runs the entire length of the Pacific coasts, from Chile to Alaska. It's larger than the entire Atlantic coast of mainland Europe several times over and extends inland for hundreds of kilometers. Outside the fault zone is mostly arid desert or something similarly hostile, excepting places like California with milder mediterreanean climates. "Don't build there" isn't really actionable.


Can you talk about an earthquake problem if the strongest earthquake recorded was 3.6? The south of the Netherlands seems to be more prone to earthquakes: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_earthquakes_in_the_N...


Not really, these are rare.

It's part of the north (mid / east of Groningen province), that has an earthquake problem.

These are mostly minor (like ~2 on Richter scale), but frequent. Causing structural damage in many (mostly older) houses, and people losing sleep over safety, house value & damage compensation. Imagine feeling minor quakes weekly, and seeing new cracks appear in the walls of your house every couple of months.

Cause of these quakes is man-made: natural gas extraction from Slochteren field. This field is slowly being closed, and subsoil will settle eventually. But that process is measured in decades. So quakes will continue for years.

Most houses affected by this, were built before Slochteren gasfield was even discovered, and earthquakes in this area didn't exist. So those houses' owners can't be blaimed for the problems they're having. Nor were those houses built with earthquakes in mind.


That's a valid point (induced quakes in otherwise stable area). Still a 3.6 is equivalent to a heavy lorry passing by (I've experienced this myself). Something a house should be able to handle without problem. The 3.6 quake was the worst quake ever for that region. Most are well below this range as you mentioned.


> most decidedly below sea level

Out of curiosity, are household-level defense measures at all common? Personal flotation and/or small boats, means for rooftop access, or such?

I will guess there can be cultural differences vis-a-vis fatalism and lack of preparation.


We're surprisingly un-individualistic when it comes down to sea defense. This shows in things like the elections for the part of government that does water management and dyke maintenance: all the parties agree on pretty much everything.

I feel like we've got more trust in the government than people in the USA do too. I fully expect that if the dykes do break the government has a rescue plan in place and a playbook on the shelf ready to get dusted off.

After the 1953 North Sea flood a lot of things happened to make sure such things would never happen again. To quote a monument on Eastern Scheldt storm surge barrier, part of the delta works: "Here rule over the tides the moon, the wind, and us."


When I lived there, no. Kids learn to swim at a really early age and that’s it.


No. No people I know of have any such devices.


It really wasn't that big of a deal. The "hurricane" was full of hype, and a lot of people, experts included, are going to look like fools tomorrow.


I was seated at a quick service place when this happened near LAX. I could feel it, but people at another table nearby engaged in a conversation missed it.


Saturated soil plus ground motion is a bad combination. Hopefully there’s not a more powerful aftershock tonight or tomorrow.


Can't tell if you mean more efficient seismic energy transmission, fault lubrication effects, weight bearing effects on faults or another theory perhaps. Care to elaborate?


Liquefaction was one of the more miserable results of the Christchurch earthquake.


An earthquake is liable to trigger a mudslide if the ground is very wet.


USGS page: https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/eventpage/ci39645386...

The epicenter is up in hills near Ventura. Any damage would be confined to the hills and probably not very much of it.


Geez they can't catch a break. I'm glad they were already in a state of emergency and people were hopefully sheltering.

My best wishes to the Southern Californians of HN


A 5.1 isn't going to do much damage in socal, especially where it was epicentered. Probably the worst is going to be knocked over liquor bottles at the supermarket. Awkward timing, but not a disaster.


Honestly the LA area is not getting much action. Little bit of rain. We kinda lucked out. Hopefully the next one misses us again.


TBH a 5.1 is not a big deal unless you're right on top of it. People near the epicenter might have to readjust some pictures on their walls, but it's not the most densely populated area


Didn't feel it here in SD, hurricane missed us too

Really glad


M 5.1 - 7 km SE of Ojai, CA 2023-08-20 21:41:00 (UTC)34.409°N 119.188°W4.8 km depth


I (nowhere near California, but living in a seismic zone) was wondering how news worthy a 5.1 was until I saw the very shallow depth you posted. Yeah, you'll really feel that one if you're nearby.


30 mi from epicenter and got a google alert before the very mild shake. More tripped out about the pre-alert and how cool that was than the quake.


Depending on how much pre alert you get you could have fun at the bar or with friends.

Or Taco Bell.


Remember: The Richter Scale is exponential.


logarithmic




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: