Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Get your DNA sequenced or checked by a private company in Canada where they don't share this information. You will pay much more but you lessen the risk of it being sold or shared to insurance companies.



This surprised me when I first heard it:

George Bush (junior) signed a law barring insurance companies from using DNA data for health insurance pricing etc.

I was surprised by this b/c my assumption was that insurance companies would want that and Republicans would push for it. The law passed 95-0 in the Senate though so this seems like, along with robocalls, something everyone is opposed to.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_Information_Nondiscrim...


> I was surprised by this b/c my assumption was that insurance companies would want that and Republicans would push for it.

The traditional view of Republicans being pro big business and Democrats fighting for the little guy don’t seem at all accurate in this day.


> in this day

In the day of George W Bush, when this was passed?


I think that still holds true for the most part, except that Democrats are also very much pro big business. The businesses they support aren't always the same though. Democrats are a lot more friendly to the entertainment industry than the fossil fuel industry for example.


I always thought Republicans are pro big business and Democrats are pro mega corps.


Good to remind people that this law won't protect you from being discriminated against when it comes to life, disability, or long-term care insurance. It also didn't keep health insurers from discriminating against you for any genetic illnesses that you already had. It was just supposed to protect you in situations where your genes showed you were more likely to develop something. Today, discrimination due to preexisting conditions may be covered by other laws.

Today pretty much every baby born has their DNA taken and that can end up being used by law enforcement, but adults can try to avoid giving their DNA to the government, drug makers, and data brokers by not using services like Ancestry.com and 23andMe.


This correct but really applies only to health insurance.

Other forms of insurance, such as life or disability, can deny you coverage based on having had genetic testing.


Yeah I don't see how this is going to be enforced. I think it's safe to say, unless you go to extraordinary lengths to ensure your genome data is safe, don't get it sequenced. A genome is forever. Like way beyond your own life. Your entire lineage and extended familys lineage.


It's enforced by insurance, employment, and health regulators with fines.

The insurance industry as a whole is relatively familiar with the law, but some employers at large are less familiar and find themselves on the wrong end of enforcement actions with EEOC: https://www.eeoc.gov/data/genetic-information-non-discrimina...


https://xkcd.com/1494/

Here's my genome: https://my.pgp-hms.org/profile/hu80855C Let me know if you can actually find anything interesting- the last time it was analyzed the genetic counsellors said I had no known genetic risks.


Of course we are not ready yet to read the genome as if we know everything, but that's just a matter of time. You can't predict the environmental component of course but that still leaves 30-70% of every trait you have or will have be predictable. For perpetuity. And not just you, but your kids as well? What are the odds they'll not be living in a totalitarian state where it's perfectly okay to persecute them based on their genetics? Why would i put them at a disadvantage potentially by already publicizing half their genome?


I mean, if my kids live in a totalitarian state, I am sure I have bigger problems than the state abusing my genome to persecute my children.


What are the privacy laws in Canada that make it more trustworthy to get this test in Canada and ensure it's not sold/shared with anyone?



Canada has an Office of the Privacy Commissioner whose job it is to actively promote privacy rights and respond to complaints about abuses: https://www.priv.gc.ca/en/about-the-opc/


The OPC also has very little enforcement power, unfortunately.


Insurance companies can't use genetic data, that's prohibited under GINA.


Not fully, others have already addressed this.


Suggestions for full genome sequencing that delete the data on their side so it's not even recoverable?


Not American but in Canada right now. How much does something like this set you back?


Palfir genetics is a company I have used for delta-32 check and some other things. Ranges from $200 and upwards. They are located in Toronto. Their website has more details about what they offer and their privacy policy is detailed.


Circling back, Palfir offers testing for greater or lesser susceptability to severe Covid https://www.palfir.com/breakthrough-research.html


Are there any particular companies that are trustworthy?




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: