Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Allowed my mind to wander for a moment - imagine if try DoJ and others had come down on the likes of Purdue pharma or big tobacco with the same zeal as they’re going after crypto.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not making excuses - just wondering why enforcement doesn’t seem to be consistent.



>Purdue pharma

There was an attempt. Dems introduced a bill (the SACKLER Act) was that would stop the bankruptcy judge in the case from granting members of the Sackler family legal immunity during the bankruptcy proceedings, however it failed to gain support.

https://thehill.com/homenews/house/544021-democrats-unveil-l...

https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/2096...


Can you educate me what the idea of the SACKLER act was?

If the Sackler family committed a felony, then surely no type of bankruptcy (corporate or personal) can shield them from that, so that's not what the act is about.

If not, then is it trying to pierce through the limited liability of a limited liability corporation? That sounds to me as potentially having huge implications. Did the Democrats really want that? Or did they just want to score some political points, and secretly did not intend to act to pass?


Have you read into that situation?

The Sackler family got the bankruptcy judge to give them and all of their companies personal immunity from a situation because the corporation was going bankrupt.

Why can a bankruptcy proceeding for one entity shield another entity from being sued?

If that entity was protected by an LLC shield such protection wouldn't be needed by the bankruptcy court.

This isn't about piercing the viel or about avoiding bankruptcy. This is about bankruptcy of one entity somehow protecting theoretically unrelated entities.

After all as you mentioned they should be shielded by the viel already, why give them explicit immunity?


That bill was introduced 20 years too late.


Any sooner and it would have been branded as anti-business.

Same reason that crypto has had a run of 14 years with almost no regulation.


Crypto has existed for 14 years, but it has only become mainstream in the last 6 years. Binance, for instance, was founded in 2017. So 6 years from founding to crackdown. OxyContin was invented in 96. The effects were already terrible in the early 2000s. A bill in 21 is too little too late.


If crypto became mainstream in 2017, how did Mt Gox even have 850k BTC to lose in 2014?

Binance may be a new company, but US-based entities like Coinbase are not. They started in 2012, and they have to comply with US regs same as Binance.


850K BTC was about $250 million in 2014. Today it’s worth 25 billion. That should give you an idea of the scale difference.


Now if we could only isolate how much of that appreciation comes from unbacked stablecoins, which didn't exist until after the Mt Gox collapse.


The SEC and DOJ let crypto scams, ponzis, unregistered securities linger for 15 years. They barely did anything. It's only now that they're starting to go after crypto after billions swindled.

If anything, SEC and DOJ have been too lenient on crypto. They should have regulated crypto as securities 12-13 years ago.


it pretty intense how much they are tightening things. I just signed up for crypto.com and it's mfa, id upload, mfa on every transaction, and a 3d face scan now (so much for anonymous bitcoin, haha). A bunch of exchanges avoid US like the plague now, can't register. I knew the USG would never ever ever tolerate any "distributed finance" except with draconian KYC and bolted to the traditional system.

I can even see them shutting down any transfers to "unauthorized" addresses eventually, you will only be allowed to play with party-approved "tokens" after you pass a full cavity search.


An interestimg implication is people already in crypto from early on may be given access to services later comers can’t get. If dollars are not freely exchangeable with crypto it’s very difficult to buy a large and growing set of goods and services. Something similar exists in some countries that have an official currency used for state stuff and an unofficial one (usually usd) that’s for everything else. The old joke being that in Cuba, it’s better to marry hotel staff than a doctor.


If dollars aren't freely exchangeable with crypto there simply won't be a 'large and growing' set of goods and services. Not even illegal ones!


Most countries and most people don’t need usd to conduct daily transactions. Why should crypto be any different?


With what zeal? Tokenbros had extremely easy life for more than a decade, despite it being obvious that almost all of them are unregistered securities. Imagine selling a contaminated pills, or advertise and sell drugs to minors for 15 years, just like scammers in tokenbro industry. Oh, wait...


On guess would be that there has already been a time where the DoJ went after those industries hard, but by now both sides have adapted to each other that obvious conflict is no longer evident?


Everything is politics.

Big tobacco employs thousands of people in the US and pays taxes. They have more senators than Binance could ever dream of. And I'm not even talking about the culture war "poisoning my body is a human right damn you liberals".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: