> sure, you can incorporate your view on difference into you calculations of how you could arrive to 5x estimation.
??
Regardless, Reddit wouldn’t prioritize a singular monthly active user (MAU) mentioned in this context. It’s more valuable for Reddit to have users who consistently visit, whether through Apollo or the official Reddit app. As long as advertising is effective and API pricing is appropriate, Reddit can generate profit.
From this perspective, what matters is the ratio of calls per view between different clients, not the type of user. It’s absurd to compare an inactive user on the official app with an active user on a third-party app. The issue at hand is unrelated to the cost of serving views or the potential revenue loss associated with those views.
In my opinion, the motivation behind these actions is 70% in response to low-effort low-value moderators (LLMs) and 30% due to the convenient timing to remove third-party apps (3PAs).
> So even if a 3PA user cost 5x in terms of compute ...
> I asked you several times to show your math how you came to 5x. Please show if you really interested in meaningful discussion.
Consider this: The Apollo app could generate significantly more requests (5x, 10x, 20x, ... ?) to serve the exact same content and still not justify the new pricing it is being charged. In other words, the app would have to be incredibly inefficient, which doesn't align with Occam's razor. It seems more plausible that Reddit has made allegations that are only loosely based on fact, rather than Apollo being so inefficient despite its high-quality reputation.
There is no specific mathematical calculation to present. I did not conduct benchmarks for you, if that's what you expected.
Your argument revolves around comparing an active 3PA user with an inactive Reddit user, which is fundamentally flawed and easily refutable. I focused on that aspect because it is not a valid comparison.
> The Apollo app could generate significantly more requests (5x, 10x, 20x, ... ?) to serve the exact same content and still not justify the new pricing it is being charged.
my hypothesis is that apollo users generate more requests because they are some power users like mods, or more engaged and active users compared to reddit MAU, so they bothered researching and installing 3p app.
> Your argument revolves around comparing an active 3PA user with an inactive Reddit user, which is fundamentally flawed and easily refutable.
no, it is people who brought that $0.15 per MAU number do such comparison.
I would compare daily active users, which are about 12x times less for reddit, and you would come to number close to $2/user.
> my hypothesis is that apollo users generate more requests because they are some power users like mods, or more engaged and active users compared to reddit MAU, so they bothered researching and installing 3p app.
Yes. It’s still silly to compare power users and non power users though in this context as I’ve pointed out.
I’m very confused about what you are attempting to say in the latter half of your reply.
However, to sum up, I wanted to reference this post from the apollo dev that came out today [0]. People who come to this thread in the future might benefit from the more detailed breakdowns and explanations with references provided there.
To you, does MAU stand for monthly active user (singular noun?)
> 250 reqs every day
Do you know the difference between a request to the API and a site visit?