Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

First reddit and now Stack Overflow? Rough couple of days for anyone googling things.



One unexpected benefit of LLM (to me) is that it memorized large parts of the internet, so it has some backup like properties. SO is down, but ChatGPT memorized it already.


It may have memorized it, but recollection with accuracy is not it's strong suit.


> SO is down, but ChatGPT memorized

memorized SO, also known as "stole". when i (and everyone else) write for SO, i give them permission to use what i write, but never did I sign up for the GPT theft of that data.


You gave them permission to use it, and they used it in such a way that GPT benefits from it as training data. I'm sorry you misplaced your trust in Stack Overflow for not protecting your public writings. Knowledge is awesome, though, in that it's like a candle and by lighting a new flame, your initial candle is not diminished in any way. It's not even your sole candle but merely one in a roaring bonfire.


> misplaced your trust in Stack Overflow

that's a great way to put it, I'm very disappointed they aren't the ones to innovate in this new direction, even though people gave them all the power (and data) to do it. Which they chose to give away to "Open" AI aka Microsoft and now spend their time bickering over GPT detectors and writing nonsensical CEO "vision" posts.

Basically, they really are now in a position to fizzle away at this rate, which is a shame, because I believe a community of acknowledged authors is a much more appealing way to advance knowledge than Microsoft anonymously milking the world for their sole profit and credit.


Your content is licensed with https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ when you submit it to SO to host and share.

You agreed that gpt can use it, so long as it includes attribution, and specifies when it makes changes


> so long as it includes attribution, and specifies when it makes changes

Does it, though?


Yes that is one of the cool side benefits i see too. It's like lossy compression for knowledge.

Although, I mean that more in the sense we can have an entire (text) internet search engine on a phone, rather than it being a full backup.


Yeah definitely. My default thought process was always, ok I'll just get a cached version, but now it's like - lemme see what GPT-4 thinks about this problem first.


I had a bash question for ChatGPT earlier and I opened with "Okay, it's just you and me now..."


I've been plugging search engine result links for reddit and stackoverflow into archive.org to "bypass" - works more or less.



One day ALL websites will go down worldwide and stay down. Could be today, could be 50 years in the future. Make sure you have a LOT of books you look forward to reading. "The Road" is not just a parable.


I think it's more likely they will go down because we have replaced them with something as far beyond websites, as websites are beyond books.


But books are not down. Why would websites go down?


Interestingly, I’ve noticed a significant drop in stackoverflow results when I Google in the recent months. Can’t really attribute it to anything, but an honest word sometimes I don’t use SO for weeks.


what? just click on "cached", SO doesn't just drop out of google




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: