Fair point. By 'kill the UI login modal', do you mean that it would be inserting something between the text fields and the login button, therefore disrupting the flow in some way? If so, I can see that.
The only problem with having 'Remember Me' auto checked is that I feel like a lot of users get bothered by it. At least personally, even when I WANT to eventually check the box, I feel like having it done for me takes the agency away from me and comes off as slimy. So, if we ran with that view (which I understand may not be the case), then it would be the next best thing in my mind to place 'remember me' higher in the flow.
Hey Jason yeah that is what I was trying to say. Login screens are so second nature to people: username, password, login... that I wonder if that extra check in between would throw them off.
I agree that the auto check does come off slimy at times, but I think I get more annoyed when I have to login to a site again vs. seeing that they already checked a box for me. Either way you have a solid argument. I'd really like to see someone do some A/B testing on this. Oh, and thanks for the response.
Yeah, in this case only data can suggest which would be the best UX route. Some A/B testing around percentage of visitors who come to the home page and login with either layout (some permutations of Remember Me checked/unchecked, Remember Me above/below login) would be interesting. Perhaps instead focusing on login pages and how they layouts perform there (vs. the home page) might be more precise because I wonder about all of the other noise that may come into play on a home page and if that noise could interfere with the precision of the testing.
