Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Interactive World History Atlas (geacron.com)
25 points by brokencode on May 2, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 13 comments



Perhaps I'm missing something, but my problem with this is that if you go back to 1AD, then most of the world is blank, e.g. suggesting that there was no history in Africa and N and S America.


"there was no history in Africa and N and S America"

By most definitions of history that is a true statement.

Wonderful and rich civilizations may have filled those blanks areas, but if there were no written accounts that survive to the modern day (or at the very least oral traditions that were eventually written down), they are by definition "pre-historic". The study of those peoples is left to the realm of archaeology and anthropology, not history. We know even less about those pre-historic civilizations that built using materials that do not stand the test of time (wood, thatch, mud, etc).


> but if there were no written accounts that survive to the modern day

There were plenty of written histories outside Europe at 1AD. E.g. the Mayan civilisation [0]. Their counting system has been traced back to 1000BC.

> The study of those peoples is left to the realm of archaeology and anthropology, not history

There is still no excuse for pretty much the whole of America being blank until about the 15th Century.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maya_civilization#Writing_and_...


No disagreement, but from what I can tell the map does indeed show Mesoamerican civilizations for which we have written records.


It’s not blank. Zoom in to see the labels for different cultures on the map. There just aren’t any defined borders.


That’s part of what I find so fascinating about this map. It’s amazing to see how little we know about the world as it was even 2000 years ago.


But we do know, it's just not shown on this page! E.g. the Mayan and Aztec civilisations. There is a massive amount of history than can be traced to the physical structures they built.

One cannot seriously claim that there was no History in Britain until the Romans arrived (or that nothing was / is known about it), which is what this map suggests. The ancient Greek Pytheas [0] visited Britain in approx 330 BC.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pytheas


The map clearly shows Mayan and Teotihuacanan civilizations in pre-colonial eras. Is the map perfect? Of course not, but I'm confused by your insistence that it's ignoring Mayan and Aztec civilizations when it plainly shows them and their predecessors.


It shows labels in the regions, just not borders. I’m assuming this is because the exact borders are unknown. Try zooming in more to see the labels.


So in 2022, nothing happened in Ukraine, and in 2020, nothing happened in Azerbaijan.

They don't show Crimea as Ukrainian controlled, at least.

I like how they have delimiting lines for Abkhazia and South Ossetia, but not coloring. Same for Kosovo.

Nothing of significance has ever happened in Bosnia.

Apparently, in 1984 Turkey has deoccupied North Cyprus.

Taiwan is China, nothing to see here.

Makes me think this map is ill-suited to display late XX century conflicts onwards.


It shows China and Taiwan as the same color, but they are labeled separately. This is technically correct as far as I’m aware, as both the PRC and ROC claim that they are the legitimate government of both China and Taiwan.

China and Taiwan are operated with separate governments and are effectively separate countries, but politically it’s quite a mess. Few countries recognize Taiwan as a separate country from China officially, even if that’s what they believe off the record.


Not everything needs to be a political statement. This is a tool for exploring historical maps, not tracking real time modern geopolitics.


This is amazingly cool. People complaining that it's not utterly complete need to get a life. This is a very cool project.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: