As someone who went through the system you are wrong. Sure that might be a few cases ruled in your favor, but in the actual implementation of the rules as applied to those in the system you are incorrect. You are like the insurance company pointing to two cases where they approved treatment saying 'look, we don't deny treatment'.
This is adjacent to my area of expertise. I do not deal with qualified immunity every day, or even every week, but my colleagues 30 feet from me do. I feel pretty confident that I know what I'm talking about.
