Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Can someone explain to me exactly how I could be harmed by this? My contact list is just a list of names and phone numbers of people I contact. Even if I had an escort service in there or something, I don't think anyone on Path's end is individually looking through the data.



An employee at Path might very well decide to start looking through that data. There have been other cases where employees gave in to temptation to access someone's data. Imagine for example if a celebrity is involved and someone decides to leak their address book.

Now one would hope that employees wouldn't have unrestricted data to this access, but one would also hope Path wouldn't do this in the first place. The fact that they collect all this information in the first place, unnecessarily and without consent does not inspire much confidence in their internal safeguards for access to this data.

Also, if anything were to happen to the company, it's hard to know what hands all that data will end up in.


I don't know any of the Path employees personally, why would they decide to go after me? The possibility seems rather remote.


Maybe not you personally, but think of the NOW scandal going on right now. Information about people's mobile contact info is valuable to a number of organizations in ways not immediately apparent.


Also, for apps with private messaging systems like Path, I'd be far more concerned about rogue employees looking through the messages I send than contact list data. I'm far more likely to have sensitive information in there.


Don't forget about the possibility of Path's data being stolen. Your contacts probably contain enough info for a criminal to carry outa pretty good phishing expedition, for example.


My Facebook friends list is already public. Seems like a motivated criminal already has more than enough info to carry out a phishing expedition. I've never really seen targeted, personalized phishing though, most phishing seems to be broad and generic "enter your bank info here" style.


This common travel scam relies on knowing of at least a pair of friends:

http://www.lastminutetravel.com/blog/index.php/2010/01/08/tr...

More details would probably make it work better, too.


"I don't think anyone on Path's end is individually looking through the data."

Oh, really? You'd be surprised. http://gawker.com/5637234/


The question isn't whether or not they are, it's the very possibility of them being able to.


But being able to do what precisely?




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: