Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If they want to improve security, they should switch from the current offer-you-can't-refuse approach to a capability/interface system. An application should always be able to successfully "list my contacts". Whether it gets the complete list, an empty list, or a less-sensitive subset should be up to me (and unknown to the app).


This would probably destroy many ad-supported apps, since users would just choose to not allow them to access the network.


Which is also why I think Google needs to make a special category for advertisers, with a group of whitelisted advertising companies that have signed privacy policy documents with Google. Then the (mandatory) permission becomes "Show me ads relevant to my interests and location" instead of 6 different permissions relating to internet, phone identity, etc. Right now you can't tell the difference between an app that innocently wants to show you some ads and an app that is about to upload the entire contents of your phone to a random ip address in china.

I would say about 80% of the permissions requested by apps are just to show ads. If they could all be wiped away with a single permission then there would be enormously less confusion and more effort could be put on highlighting the truly dangerous permissions.


Many ad-supported apps check that they can access their ad servers and won't start otherwise. I flashed a new ROM that had adblocking without me knowing and SSHDroid (which I'm happy to have ads for) didn't work.


So then Google doesn't have to make that an option on stock android (although droidwall currently takes care of that quite nicely). The restrictive option for internet access could be a low quota for people concerned with data usage.

The open source android distributions would hopefully go further and empower their users with control over their devices.


CyanogenMod lets you change permissions of apps: http://review.cyanogenmod.com/#change,4055

They drew the line at letting you spoof unique IDs for privacy purposes though http://review.cyanogenmod.com/#change,5677


Except (AFAIK) the API calls fail when a permission has been revoked. A non-defensively coded application will most likely crash when it tries to use a revoked permission. A developer has little motivation to support a user taking app permissions into their own hands. What really needs to happen is for the call to return a sensible value for what the application is allowed to access. It would even be handy to return a subset of the contacts list, say if a user is willing to take a risk of spamming friends but not professional contacts. A user would set the base permission for all newly installed apps, and would increase an app's permission after they used it long enough to trust it. The only thing the current system does is fake consent for misbehaving apps.

I am aware of that rejected patch, and I can only hope that the CM people will overcome their fear in the future (or maybe a security-conscious friendly fork).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: