Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

A lot of people are thinking about this but too slowly

GPT and the world's nerds are going after the "wouldnt it be cool if..."

While the black hats, nations, intel/security entities are all weaponizing behind the scenes while the public has a sandbox to play with nifty art and pictures.

We need an AI specific PUBLIC agency in government withut a single politician in it to start addressing how to police and protect ourselves and our infrastructure immediately.

But the US political system is completely bought and sold to the MIC - and that is why we see carnival games ever single moment.

I think the entire US congress should be purged and every incumbent should be voted out.

Elon was correct and nobody took him seriously, but this is an existential threat if not managed, and honestly - its not being managed, it is being exploited and weaponized.

As the saying goes "He who controls the Spice controls the Universe" <-- AI is the spice.




AI is literally the opposite of spice, though. In Dune, spice is an inherently scarce resource that you control by controlling the sole place where it is produced through natural processes. Herbert himself was very clear that it was his sci-fi metaphor for oil.

But AIs can be trained by anyone who has the data and the compute. There's plenty of data on the Net, and compute is cheap enough that we now have enthusiasts experimenting with local models capable of maintaining a coherent conversation and performing tasks running on consumer hardware. I don't think there's the danger here of anyone "controlling the universe". If anything, it's the opposite - nobody can really control any of this.


Regardless!

The point is that whomever the Nation State is that has the most superior AI will control the world information.

So, thanks for the explanation (which I know, otherwise I wouldn't have made the reference.)


I still don't see how it would control it. At best, it'd be able to use it more effectively.

The other aspect of the AI arms race is that the models are fundamentally not 100% controllable; and the smarter they are, the more that is true. Yet, ironically, making the most use out of them requires integrating them into your existing processes and data stores. I wouldn't be at all surprised if the nation-states with the best AIs will end up with their own elites being only nominally in charge.


Im more thinking a decade out.

This is one thing I despise about the American POlitical System - they are literally only thinking 1 year out, because they only care about elections and bribes and insider trading.

China has a literal 100 year plan - and they are working to achieve it.

I have listened to every single POTUS SoTU speach for the last 30 years. I have heard the same promises from every single one...

What should be done is to take all the SoTU transcripts over the years and find the same, unanswered empy promises and determine who said them, and which companies lobbied to stop the promises through campaign donations (bribes).

Serious, in 48 years, I have seen corruption expand, not diminish - it just gets more sophisticated (and insidious) -- just look at Pelosi's finances to see, and anyone who denies its is an idiot. She makes secret trades with the information that she gets in congress through her son.


Pelosi's trades are her broker cycling her accounts for fees. She actually lost money on the ones people were complaining about.

China definitely does not have 100 year plans, and you don't understand the point of planning if you think any of them can be valid more than a few years out.



They do not have a 100 year plan because you can't have one of those. They can't exist. It doesn't matter if they think they have one.

China has a personalist government centered around Xi, so if he dies there go his plans.

Here's ours: https://slate.com/human-interest/2015/11/en-lan-2000-is-a-se...


Very few companies have the data and compute needed to run the top end models currently...




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: