Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

This gets posted again and again, and every time I look at it, the code quality is absolutely terrible. Remote access software is by design a complete internet-accessible backdoor to your system, I will never use one that is written as shoddily as this one.



Also note their persistent refusal to implement TLS for their web access. This attitude alone tells me never to trust this project ever, even when they finally should use TLS.

Sadly there is no other FOSS out there that combines remote support with good NAT traversal. Existing remote access tools such e.g. VNC all do not offer NAT traversal and are incredibly hard to setup. All FOSS web/phone conference tools offering screen sharing refuse to implement transferring Cursor/Keyboard control. Probably because it is not so easy, but mostly, I guess, out if fear for diffuse security problems.

Too bad people then will be compelled to use this absolute mess...


I work on the Desktop Access feature for Teleport: https://goteleport.com/docs/desktop-access/getting-started/

The tool itself is open core: https://github.com/gravitational/teleport

Most of the desktop access stuff is open source. (The only desktop related thing that's proprietary is our tool that allows for access to machines not connected to Active Directory). A sizeable chunk of the desktop access code is even Written In Rust™: https://github.com/gravitational/teleport/tree/master/lib/sr...!


Are you talking about their website, rustdesk.com? It looks like they have HTTPS version of "rustdesk.com" but don't redirect to it automatically.

Do you have any links to issues/interactions you find concerning? I've been evaluating different remote desktop tools recently and I'd certainly like to know about any other red flags.


I think I found the issue: https://github.com/rustdesk/rustdesk/issues/856

Furthermore they seem to share servers with what seems like an unrelated ecommerce website: https://github.com/rustdesk/rustdesk/issues/2712

It doesn't seem like they take security all that seriously.


It's written in Rust, it can't be terrible! /s


Are there any other remote desktop services what work out of the box to access servers behind firewalls and has clients for mobile and all desktop devices?

not to criticize your answer, i just have not found any viable alternative that is free to use for all use cases.


whats the commercial options code quality looking like?


Ssh x11 forwarding is at least supremely battle tested over decades.


Yup and unfortunately a feature that Wayland decided wasn't worth preserving.


Waypipe exists.


Maybe not much better, but that's hardly the only alternative


Could you share what you use?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: