On: ChatGPT Plus

[dpistole]

I think your interpretation of "free as in beer" is the opposite of the mainstream (where my understanding is it means "free of charge")

[erulabs → dpistole]

It is - but the mainstream “free as in beer” makes no sense. Who gives away free beer? Beer is free as in libre, not free as in gratis!

But you’re correct - the mainstream meaning of that term is the opposite - which I find bizarre.

[dpistole → erulabs]

I think it makes sense in the "beer is tangible" and "speech is not" sense (to my brain anyway). If I saw a "free beer" sign in a window I'd probably be inclined to think (albeit suspiciously) that there might be a frosty mug inside at no cost to me. Whereas if I saw a "free speech" sign, I'd assume they support my right to say whatever I want (or I suppose maybe that there's a lecture going on inside with no admittance fee).

We all got different brains though, shoutout learning from others perspectives, ty for sharing yours.

[gardenhedge → dpistole]

There's nothing to learn from his incorrect perspective. It means available at no cost.

[dragonwriter → erulabs]

> It is - but the mainstream “free as in beer” makes no sense. Who gives away free beer?

The quote references it because it is (or was) a cliché promotional offering.

[webmaven → erulabs]

Try this on for size: "open as in bar".