Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Fund your 401(k) to the maximum. Fund your IRA to the maximum.

How is this not buying stocks? Is he suggesting putting all this money in a savings account paying 3% interest?



Adams argues that the individual should not be buying individual stocks.

I tend to disagree for individuals willing to keep up with their stocks, and can read 10-Qs and other investment material. if you're doing the "buy and ignore" thing, however, it doesn't make much sense.

I've been guilty of not being as active as I should be, relying on meta information far too often. However, the vast majority of my investment is outside individual stocks and in indexes.


Right, he's saying don't trade individual stocks, buy indexes instead. I fully subscribe to this view, unless the individual is trading for a living (putting in many hours), and has enough capital that they aren't wiping out their gains (relative to the index) with trading costs and the opportunity cost of their time. IMO, you can read all the investment material that you like, but if you have access to the same information as the market then you wont outperform the market on a gross basis, and if you have lesser scale than professional traders then you will under-perform it on a net basis (after costs).


Sorry, but let me get this straight. There are people out there that buy stocks before contributing to their 401k's? Aren't 401's tax deferable? Aren't normal capital gains taxable?

This is about as dumb as putting money into your savings account before paying off your cc debt.

Math. I suppose it's not everyone's strong point.


401ks often get a company match as well, which is a wonderful thing.


And you can trade individual stocks in your 401k.


I can't.


I should have qualified that - your company's 401k partner needs to support it. We use fidelity where I work, and you can sign up for a self directed brokerage link account. This is a relatively new option for us.


401(k)s can contain many types of assets, depending on the provider. For example, mine has stock-only indexes, bond indexes, mixed funds (stocks and bonds) but ALSO it has fixed income funds, which return ~4.8% pa. That's not going to make you salivate, but it's not a bad place to be if you believe the market is over priced.

401(k)s can (and should) be invested across a portfolio of different asset classes (and geos) according to your retirement needs. Asset allocations should be changed over time as retirement nears. this is my personal opinion, not financial advice :)


401k != stocks. You can have it in a money market account while still receiving the 401k/IRA benefits.


These days, it's probably safer to just be in stock. :)


haha touche. Man the beer is going to taste extra good tonight.


The article isn't titled well. Three of the 9 rules involve buying stock.


Presumably he wants you to do it like this:

> Take whatever money is left over and invest 70% in a stock index fund and 30% in a bond fund through any discount broker, and never touch it until retirement




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: