Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Twitter's status page shows “no incidents reported” for Dec. 28 global outage (twitterstat.us)
80 points by trynewideas on Dec 29, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 19 comments


Could just be dysfunction, but Musk’s behavior makes it look more likely it’s an intentional lie: his only comments have been “Works for me” in the midst of it [1], and “Significant backend server architecture changes rolled out. Twitter should feel faster.” just after [2].

[1]: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1608273870901096454

[2]: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1608324539779551232


Even if it wasn't intentional, it's not like he's going to admit it.


It could be ChatGPT


I wonder if anyone left knows about the status page, or has access/ability to edit it. Or, more cynically, even cares.

Sometimes these parts of the processes, especially where there's external comms, are controlled so only specific teams can communicate to the public and put out an official message. If all those comms, incident management, etc teams were cut, it'll take a while to regain control of the site.

Typically you'd want your status page hosted on different infra too, so it doesn't go down when your main infra does, or even easier, out with a SaaS provider. There are a bunch who provide this.

This one is StatusPage (Atlassian) and those licenses to get edit access aren't that cheap either. Not something you'd just hand out to everyone in tech and comms regardless.


> Typically you'd want your status page hosted on different infra too, so it doesn't go down when your main infra does, or even easier, out with a SaaS provider. There are a bunch who provide this.

There's a https://status.twitterstat.us/ (redirected from http://status.twitter.com) that should serve that purpose, but it displays even less information


Looks like both are external then.

StatusPage (api.twitterstat.us) is Atlassian hosted, and looks like it's just the API status.

status.io (status.twitterstat.us) is another SaaS vendor and is the the main status page for Twitter (as linked off Twitter.com)

Why you'd need both/different vendors for each component is beyond me though. Both will allow you to show various product components in one place.

Twitterstat.us itself top-level goes nowhere. I wonder if that's deliberate.


I wonder if this is a deliberate attempt to try to claim later there was no Dec. 28 outage. After all, in a year or two the Twitter status page will be considered pretty authoritative in online debates.


> After all, in a year or two the Twitter status page will be considered pretty authoritative in online debates.

The outage was widespread enough that mainstream (non-tech) news outlets reported on it. If anything, not including it undermines the trust in Twitter's status page as an authoritative reference.


Nowdays people can just reply “fake news”.


Today, sure. But in 2 years, most people won't remember that.


Amazing. I love that the response is "works for me".


Interesting, the status page blocks Mullvad (Edge reports: It looks like api.twitterstat.us closed the connection). Twitter itself works fine. Doesn't seem to be an Atlassian thing, given that Dropbox's status page works fine.


So, using the same method that Musk has been for reporting on hate content since the takeover thaf has it going down, while every external source monitoring Twitter has it going way up.



What was the incident?



Was it really only “tens of thousands” or is that just incomplete reporting?


That’s just the number that indicated a complaint on “down detector”. It was vastly more than that.


Ahh gotcha. Thanks.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: