Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Seconded. Seeing some articles written by people signalling that they don’t like Elon Musk’s Twitter takeover, by announcing that they’re migrating to Mastodon makes me wonder why they don’t just step down from their digital stage altogether and join the rest of us.

I suppose they’ll need to pen an article about it first to let us know.




I'm not really a seasoned user of either, but my take for now:

1. Mastodon has different dynamics than Twitter. Rather than throwing a bunch of stuff I didn't ask for in an effort to boost "engagement", Mastodon just gives me exactly what I asked for. This results in a slow moving feed of nothing but what I subscribe to. I like it.

2. Mastodon seems to have a much better content/noise ratio and to be better moderated. I don't want to be surrounded by hateful people. I'm not looking for a "public square". I'm looking for pleasant and useful interactions.


That's more or less my argumentation on the "EU Voice" thread (and for sure being down-voted to death :))

I don't like EU signalling that Elon Musk is bad for the democracy, while the other people there were good. That was never the case.

I don't think EU should spend money and time on that (unless the EU politicians step down from Twitter and stop to see that as our virtual Agora)


What does the EU instance have to do with any of this? The instance started before there was any talk of anyone buying Twitter.

edit: HN won't let me reply, so:

--

I had a whole comment written, but you deleted and remade before I posted, and I lost what I wrote.

But the gist is, no, the existence of the instance alone has nothing to do with Musk.

It could possibly have nudged them to speed up existing plans, but that's not the same as "EU signalling that Elon Musk is bad for the democracy." It's them signaling proprietary social media under the influence of a non-EU power is bad for democracy in the EU.

This is one of the possible failure modes they hoped to avoid by exploring alternatives to commercial social media. The conversations are long-running and high-level.

For example, from 2019: https://ar.al/2019/11/29/the-future-of-internet-regulation-a...


> I had a whole comment written, but you deleted and remade before I posted, and I lost what I wrote.

Looks like I had twice the same comment, and I had to delete one, sorry.


did it start before end january? That's when Musk started it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33504670




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: