Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Don't link to mobile wikipedia. It is incredibly rude to people who want the normal site, while being of zero benefit to people who want the mobile site.


I aspire to a life where my scale of rude behavior tops out with a stranger using the mobile version of an interesting link on an online message board.


That used to annoy me a lot, but then I installed https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/skip-mobile-w... and forgot about it.


it annoys me a lot, but I don't blame it on the people posting, but on the people who put a one way trap door in the code on the site

that's on top of my annoyance with the huge number of people who didn't understand what was good about original html markup and set about adding pixel counts and thinking they needed to know the screen size etc. It's the same people who don't understand unix.


Seriously, why can't the same page just be responsive? Why do we need two different domains even, instead of the server serving a desktop or mobile page? Why does the mobile page not redirect back to desktop?

So many odd choices.


The Wikipedia page is just responsive. The Wikipedia Mobile page has a dedicated URL, and it assumes that, if you went to the trouble of requesting it specifically, that's because you specifically wanted it.


But it doesn't, if you go to the desktop site it redirects you to the mobile site. The desktop site isn't responsive, you get the desktop view on the phone, sidebar and all.


It has been said that mobile wikipedia is more user friendly on any platform, basically a more modern user interface than the standard desktop interface. Thus having benefit to everyone.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: