Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Just like with non-AI parties, I assume MP elected from these parties will retain the very human and individualistic right to go rogue and vote with their conscience not according to parties dictates



Is this some kind of joke I'm too Canadian to understand? Almost every vote here is whipped and all party members toe the line every time.


Not a joke. Don't know deeply about all parliamentary cultures around the world but here[1] is an example of a small party that finally got 1 MP elected (2019) only to expel this MP from the party within months of the election due to disagreement over policy voting.

It is my understanding that in most (all?) democracies MP's legitimacy arise from the electorate, not the party. The party may strip the membership from an MP but can't strip them from the elected office.

This may be more likely to happen in proportional representation[2] parliaments than in majoritarian systems of representation, specially for up and coming and small parties. Denmark follows [2].

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIVRE

[2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation


Really? Even the United States blue and red parties don't all vote in unison.


Yes, it’s the same in Australia. Party line is strongly whipped, except on very specific issues where the party says you can vote what you want (usually a “conscience vote”, very rare). There is generally an extensive backroom caucus.

The idea of Joe Manchin wouldn’t really make sense there, nor would the idea of having multiple factions within a party voting against each other.

As a result people from across the country appear much more similar. A Queenslander and a Victorian don’t politically differ the way a Californian and Texan do.


Exactly! Politicians like Machin and Sinema don't exist here, those types get run out of parties here. Same with "conscience votes" being rare, its actually a newsworthy event when parties let their members vote freely.


> A Queenslander and a Victorian don’t politically differ the way a Californian and Texan do.

Maybe not the same way. But One Nation and Clive Palmer are based in one state and not the other. There are political differences between QLD and VIC.


The AI isn't actually able to hold a seat, so the plan is to have humans "act as a medium for it."

Also,

"So far, The Synthetic Party has only 11 signatures out of the 20,000 that would make it eligible to run in this November’s election."

So the specifics of how the members would vote might be something they can get away with hand-waving.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: