Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Every time I read about natural history and ancestral human species I feel some sort of epiphany.

For thousand years all we had to fill up our ignorance was Adam & Eve and Noah's Ark and all those dumb religious fairy tales.

Now we have evidences to understand what we really are. And all of that was discovered just in the last 150 years.




> For thousand years all we had to fill up our ignorance was Adam & Eve and Noah's Ark and all those dumb religious fairy tales.

Myths are more than mere stories. Joseph Campbell illustrated four functions of myths: metaphysical, cosmological, sociological and psychological. Campbell also neatly summarizes in his 1949 work, The Hero with a Thousand Faces,

Dream is the personalized myth, myth the depersonalized dream; both myth and dream are symbolic in the same general way of the dynamic of the psyche. But in the dream the forms are quirked by the peculiar troubles of the dreamer, whereas in myth the problems and solutions sown are directly valid for all mankind.

An astute quote by Ludwig Wittgenstein is very applicable to your shallow description,

Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.


To give you some extra context, because I sympathize the OP's message, while acknowledging the wording is disrespectful - growing up in a religious environment you are taught that certain things are true, and can encounter strong opposition to basic questioning. This can lead to a state where eing exposed to an alternative truth is exciting and interesting.


To provide a counterpoint, that is true for some religious environments but not others.

In some you are taught that the world is a beautiful and fascinating place. To question, explore, and try to understand it gives you a greater appreciation for its maker.


Perhaps I'm old and tired, but I think that the chances of finding out what's actually going on are so absurdly remote that the only thing to do is to say, "Hang the sense of it," and keep yourself busy. I'd much rather be happy than right any day.


A human can't understand the entirety of the universe, but can still enjoy small truths when they find them.

If you really want an old school opinion, I also think there are a lot more important things to life than happiness.

You don't have to go too far back in time before the idea of hedonism was disgusting.


Why respect theories that can't be falsified?


Because not everything is science.


With sympathy to the parent poster, who may have grown up in a religious tradition that tries to equate biblical truth with historical/scientific truth across the board, remember that the concept that there is such a thing as scientific truth, or at least a scientific explanation, is itself pretty modern.

The origin stories are about creating identity and revealing deep aspects of psychology and sociology. They may also contain echos of earlier events.

They were not written to fill up ignorance, but to teach wisdom.

Taught that way, they contain many helpful insights.

The claim that Adam and Eve is "literally what happened" is ridiculous on its face. Talking snakes? Really?

But there is a lot of wisdom in the story.


Different societies have different legends, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadza_people:

"One telling of Hadza's oral history divides their past into four epochs, each inhabited by a different culture. According to this tradition, in the beginning of time the world was inhabited by hairy giants called the akakaanebee "first ones" or geranebee "ancient ones". The akakaanebee did not possess tools or fire; they hunted game by running it down until it fell dead; they ate the meat raw. They did not build houses but slept under trees, as the Hadza do today in the dry season. In older versions of this story, fire was not used because it was physically impossible in the earth's primeval state, while younger Hadza, who have been to school, say that the akakaanebee simply did not know how.

In the second epoch, the akakaanebee were succeeded by the xhaaxhaanebee "in-between ones", equally gigantic but without hair. Fire could be made and used to cook meat, but animals had grown more wary of humans and had to be chased and hunted with dogs. The xhaaxhaanebee were the first people to use medicines and charms to protect themselves from enemies and initiated the epeme rite. They lived in caves.

The third epoch was inhabited by the people of hamakwanebee "recent days", who were smaller than their predecessors. They invented bows and arrows, and containers for cooking, and mastered the use of fire. They also built huts like those of Hadza today. The people of hamakwabee were the first of the Hadza ancestors to have contact with non-foraging people, with whom they traded for iron to make knives and arrowheads. They also invented the gambling game lukuchuko.

The fourth epoch continues today and is inhabited by the hamayishonebee "those of today". When discussing the hamayishonebee epoch, people often mention specific names and places, and can approximately say how many generations ago events occurred."




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: