Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Be careful what you signal (economist.com)
15 points by cwan on Nov 29, 2011 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments



The classic example:

http://www.pickpocket.com/Pickpocket-Prevention-Tips.asp

"Be wary of signs that read "Pickpockets About" or someone yelling, "There's a pickpocket in the crowd." They aren’t always what they seem.

> I use this ploy a lot in my show. When people find out that I can pick pockets, the men check for their wallets and the women will check for their jewelry in the order of value -- most expensive first. Their actions clue me as to exactly where the wallets and valuable jewelry are located.


I always think of this when I have my laptop with me in the car. I worry that if I leave it in the car, a would be thief will walk by and see it. But, if I take my backpack out and put it in the drunk it is a huge signal that "my backpack has something very valuable in it!" to anyone who might be watching. Since you can get into the trunk by breaking a window and pushing a button, I think on net, it is safer to leave my backpack in the car.


Consider that the number of people who might walk by and look in your car window is much larger than the number of people who happen to see you at the exact moment you put your backpack in the trunk. It's safer to not leave it in view of passersby.

It's even safer to get in the habit of putting it in an inconspicuous location when you get into the car.


I think about this often. Usually I try to put my laptop in the trunk when I get in the car, if I anticipate having to leave my laptop in the car when I park it. However, if I have to relocate the laptop to the trunk when I park, I'll will always just put it in the trunk because the trunk in my car can be locked from the interior trunk release.


> simply draw attention to the fact that the driver is a nervous tool owner.

Or rather, nervous about break-ins, which are damaging whether or not there are tools or other valuables in the van. A broken window costs money to replace; a jimmied door costs money to fix.


It reminds me of the sign "Handguns not allowed in store." This basically signals thieves that the law abiding citizens who have permits to carry a concealed weapon didn't bring them into the store with them.


So I should heed a warning based on a conclusion arrived at entirely using conjecture? Thanks for that.


Are they trying to avoid having the windows broken (to find nothing) or avoid having their tools stolen (deception -they tools are actually there)?

Maybe the solution is to just leave the windows down/doors unlocked? Not sure what to do about rainy days.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: