Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

My main problem with planting trees is - you're not planting seeds, but seedlings. These seedlings were already growing elsewhere, you just burned some fuel to transport them to another place.

Additionally at least in my region whenever I leave a plot of land unattended for a few years - tree appear on it. If you leave it for more than a decade it becomes a forest.

So - it seems the important part is assigning land for forests and not bothering the trees that will grow there. The tree-planting is optional.



The amount of fuel used by transporting 10,000 seedlings is easily sequestered by just one of them growing.


But it was growing already. The bottleneck is land allocated for trees, not the tree-planting procedure (in fact it's automatic once you have some trees in vicinity).


No, you get trees for planting from a nursery, not from the wild. And tree planting is not "automatic"


Are you sure? A forest grew on my grandpa's field automatically about 15 years after he stopped using it (mostly as a cow pasture). Nobody planted anything, we just left it be.

In 2008 this was a grass field, we made campfires there. Now it's a forest: https://goo.gl/maps/rSeprtz7orYAwVPY8

In fact if you don't mow a lawn for a few months saplings start appearing :) Forests are perfectly good at spreading by themselves, they evolved for millions of years to do that. If you want more trees you just need to let them grow.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: