Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Odd: Israel Banning Planes with Four Engines (onemileatatime.com)
14 points by myth_drannon on Sept 4, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 5 comments



If you look at the source cited in the article, it's not a ban on 4 engine planes as a whole, it's a ban explicitly at Ben Gurion airport due to noise concerns, as it's surrounded by urban areas. The residents of those areas have been complaining for many years about noise.

There are other airports in Israel that can accommodate large, 4 engine aircraft in terms of runway. ETM and VDA come to mind but the former may not have the passenger handling capacity and the latter is now mostly closed to civilian aviation


Honestly, it sounds like a politician trying to win “green” brownie points while doing nothing substantial


It may be newer 2 engine aircraft are net better in "MPG" terms for freight, and pax loading for Israel doesn't demand 380/747 class craft. The jumbo 747 fleet is ageing, its old motor technology. Newer jumbos are exclusively freight.

Israel imposes far higher safety pre checks on pax. Maybe unit transfer costs in the system as a whole through their enhanced security simply scale better in lower units of pax as a single arrival?

Or maybe this reflects some local issues around noise, pollution, or when just some bizarre muscle flex by a specific segment of the political weirdness of the Knesset?


Meh. Doubtful. Israel has trades even with hostile countries "under the table". What's the point hurting local tourism?


This website is notorious for clickbait. This article doesn’t really contribute any value.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: