Sorry, but MyPy and friends can barely hold a candle to what actual static-typing systems do - Rust, Haskell, OCaml, Typescript, even .Net (C#/F#) offer more safety and guarantees.
Type hints in python are _just that_, they're hints. The whole "typed" python ecosystem relies on packages and the language using them, using them correctly, and using them consistently. In my experience so far, I've seen little widespread use, and nothing from core python, which is a huge hole IMO.
> Sorry, but MyPy and friends can barely hold a candle to what actual static-typing systems do - Rust, Haskell, OCaml, Typescript, even .Net (C#/F#) offer more safety and guarantees.
Note that you don't include the most common static languages there (cpp, java, golang), you include languages known *specifically " for their extremely powerful type systems, one of which , just like mypy, uses gradual typing!
I mean sure, we can include C++, go and java in there if you want? I don’t really know what the point you’re making here is?
> one of which , just like mypy, uses gradual typing!
This is like arguing that because your scooter also has a petrol engine, it’s as fast and efficient as an F1 car. My argument was that MyPy doesn’t compete with the capabilities of modern statically typed languages. TS might also technically be gradually typed, but most devs I know just go straight to fully typed TS, because working in a mix/gradual environment is painful and the community uptake of strict types is far higher.
What features that Javas type system provides does pythons lack?
I can name dozens that python has that Java doesn't. My point is that if you include cpp or java or golang the statement becomes false. Python's type system is actually generally speaking more robust than those (cpp is comparable, but I don't think python's is worse).
So I'm asking, be specific what capabilities does mypy lack that cpp or java or golang provide? Keep in mind, mypy supports literal types, limited dependent types, dynamic-duck typing (protocols), limited contract types, and more. Java doesn't, go doesn't. Cpp supports some of those but it requires arcane incantations.
Type hints in python are _just that_, they're hints. The whole "typed" python ecosystem relies on packages and the language using them, using them correctly, and using them consistently. In my experience so far, I've seen little widespread use, and nothing from core python, which is a huge hole IMO.