Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

A blanket rule on data collection isn't tampering with evidence. They are not examining the particular information they are deleting in order to determine whether it is potentially evidence.



> They are not examining the particular information they are deleting in order to determine whether it is potentially evidence.

Of course they are, unless I am misunderstanding what they are doing. It seems that they are specifically deleting location data with regards to visits to abortion clinics. [1]

[1]: https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/google-data-abortion-clinics-1...


There is no such thing as an abortion clinic, there are facilities that provide a range of healthcare services, potentially including abortions.


> a range of healthcare services

Come on man, that's just muddying the water. The courts do care about intent, and Google's intent is clear in this case.

Also, that's like saying there is no such thing as a gun shop, just a retail business providing access to various kinds of gear.


Their intent is pretty clearly to protect the privacy of women seeking healthcare at facilities that do provide abortions. But they are not peeking at what sort of healthcare the women are seeking. There's a clear distinction.

"Without regard to the purpose of their visit" is going to pass muster pretty much anywhere.


> Their intent is pretty clearly to protect the privacy of women seeking healthcare at facilities that do provide abortions

And they just happen to think of that after the recent supreme court ruling?


That doesn't matter!


IANAL, so I don't know about that, but one would hope that the judiciary isn't too dumb.


The fact that people are willing to conflate visits to those facilities with seeking abortion is itself a clear justification to discard all data about visits to those facilities!


There is no conflation on my part, it's just clearly evidence in that direction.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: