Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Missouri considers law to make illegal to ‘aid or abet’ out-of-state abortion (pbs.org)
13 points by alwillis on June 27, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments



Its not immediately obvious to me why this would not fall afoul of regulating interstate commerce being left to the federal government.

Abortions (like all healthcare) are indisputably a commercial activity. And if somebody is traveling across state lines to do it, then it is obviously interstate commercial activity.

States are not allowed to regulate interstate commercial activity. (This is the so called "Dormant Commerce Clause").


From the article:

Like a Texas law passed last year, the bill puts enforcement in the hands of residents, who could file lawsuits against those they believe have violated it.

It gets around the state regulating interstate commerce by having residents—not the state itself—enforce it, which is what Texas has been doing for 10 months now.


How would this work? Applicable to Missouri citizens only? Can someone renounce their statehood but still live there?


>Like a Texas law passed last year, the bill puts enforcement in the hands of residents, who could file lawsuits against those they believe have violated it.

So, even if they win the lawsuit, how will collection be enforced? Will individuals have the right to levy income or place liens against property?


It's a civil suite; if it's like the Texas law, they'll have to pay the fine ($10,000) plus legal fees and court costs, which the court will enforce.


Right, but which employee of the court actually goes after collection? (That's why I asked about levies and liens). It's not a fine payable to the state, but rather to the plaintiff. Just because someone gets a bill doesn't mean they will pay it. The IRS goes after tax delinquents, but they are not a court. The county tax assessor goes after delinquent property tax, but they are not a court.


soon you'll need to expatriate from your HOA, County, State and Country and still get taxed out of each.


California was talking about a 'exit tax' in 2020 but I don't think they went through with it.

http://scocablog.com/exit-taxes-in-california-not-so-fast/




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: