Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's not free speech if only the 'right' speech is protected.


Personally, I respect the ACLU's freedom to not collaborate with fascists.


Ah,so you do respect freedoms,but only the ones you agree with?

A very short-sighted point of view. What happens of down the road someone decides what you think, believe, or say, is wrong?

I'd quote Niemöller but I fear it would fall on deaf ears, (or blind eyes, I guess).


It is not a slippery slope. Nazis very specifically called for the death of millions of "out group" people.

I'll start worrying someone will stop protecting my right to speech when I call for the deaths of all people fitting some category.

It's that simple.


Prolly a good call not to use a quote about Nazi atrocities and how they can't be given an inch to defend the notion that Nazis should be given pro-bono legal defense.


Hardly. It was about standing up for someone regardless of whether you agree with them or not. Had anyone stood up against the atrocious acts in the beginning, they may not have gotten as far.

ie- This isn't about their beliefs, it's about the right to free speech. If no one stands up now, who will be left to stand for you when your time comes.

edit- I once had to take a friend of mine to her abortion appointment. The vitriol screamed at us both (they assumed incorrectly I was the father), was mind-blowing. They brought her to tears, were screaming in her face. It got ugly until I screamed right back. The fury I felt that day was incomprehensible to most people. Literally saw red. Had to comfort my friend afterwards. To me it was evil, spiteful, hateful shit to spew at someone at their lowest and most vulnerable.

They still had the right to spew that garbage.

The times it's hard to swallow can sometimes be the most important.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: